Kluge Scholars @ Columbia vs. Fordham Honors programs and dean's scholarship?

Of course it does. It’s never a bargain to pursue something that was not your goal in the first place.

Fordham was a last minute safety school. How closely has the OP scrutinized what they offer and what they don’t?

All things being equal. I agree with your point. That’s as long as all things actually are equal.

BTW, I love Fordham and sent my son there.