<p>I completely disagree. Though academy grads may be subjected to much leadership though their time in the Yard, ROTC midshipmen have a certain life’s experience that can only be acquired through interaction with people on a personal level. You won’t find a plebe on the yard going up and having the confidence to approach a group of firsties and have a comfortable conversation with them about their past experiences, and you won’t find said plebe talking to them during chow. in my opinion, ROTC produces much more well rounded leaders. According to many officers Academy grads come out of the academy, much cocker than they should be, and the last thing a chief wants in a cocky JO with ZERO experience under his belt to come in and jack up everything. </p>
<p>Bottom line: Theres a reason why the term “ring tappers” has a negative connotation in the fleet</p>