Let’s talk Mah Jong!

I surprisingly have received quite a bit of pushback on my stance for my free speech

One person told me they were trying to class things up. I said I guess I’m classless then.

I get the feeling I’m being a pill for pushing back on what I think is a ridiculous idea

It IS a ridiculous idea.

4 Likes

I went on a cruise last week and my cabin was on the same floor as the game/card room. There were several tables of people playing mahjongg and I stopped by to show interest and hoped they’d ask me to play but no. The woman setting up spoke very little English (many Asians on this cruise).

Lots of people of all ages playing games in this room and on the upper decks, everything from cards to board games to chess and backgammon. I just watched baseball.

Sorry for what?

2 Likes

What’s wrong with saying you’re sorry?

1 Like

Exactly!

Yesterday two people wanted the same tile. I was the player nearest so the tile was mine. I said, sorry I took your tile :grin:. That is apparently very annoying to this person.

The other issue and maybe I’m projecting. My next door neighbor plays occasionally. She’s not very good, she doesn’t have a great sense of the game.

She’s deeply insecure, has had a very traumatic and abusive life. She is very grateful for the opportunity to play even though she is not good.

She does apologize all the time. I am FIERCELY PROTECTIVE of my friend.

I think some people think if they just tell people not to do something, they will stop. My neighbor will not come anymore and she is very happy to have this activity.

Sometimes these things feel like junior high and I’m not very good at junior high.

4 Likes

Would she prefer “ha ha sucker, that tile is MINE?”

6 Likes

That is so ridiculous. I could not play with people like this- I’d have to find a new group. When I joined my monthly group I knew most ladies but some not so well. Turns out we are all on the same page- have fun, laugh, help each other out to learn getting better but always be nice!

2 Likes

Am still very ambivalent about playing. If people want to play, play. There is plenty of time to chatty chat between games and when setting up the walls. As one who is still learning (as are the others I am playing with), I need a little bit of time during the Charleston to think about what I want to pass. And when I have tiles that could go towards 2 different hands, I am trying to count what I have and what to choose. If the other players are yakking while I am trying to to concentrate I find it very difficult. And if I ask if they could please give me a minute to think, they whisper instead of talking loud. Maybe I was too subtle. Maybe I should ask them to shush. Sheesh.

And while I am griping, when playing Mah Jong, its not the time to talk politics, IMO.

3 Likes

And that’s why i left my group. I put up with it for a long time, but I just got tired of hearing about their opinions, even if I agreed with them.

2 Likes

Mahjong, for me, is an exercise in learning to have fun with people unlike myself. Some people are more competitive, others less so. Some like to gab during the games, others don’t. I try to be on my best behavior because the opportunity to play and learn is most important to me.

Would talking directly to the bossy person help? She may think that she’s conveying compassion to your friend by saying without saying that she doesn’t need to keep apologizing, that we are all learning. I’m probably giving the bossy person too much credit.

2 Likes

Just got home from a 3+ hour afternoon of mahjong with my regular group. The 4 of us try to play together every week. None of us would ever want to play with someone who set that kind of rule!

Our only goal is to have fun. We’ve all been playing about a year and a half and noticed today that we’ve all really improved. Our games are going faster, but we’re never going to get really serious about it. For us, Mahjong is a great reason to eat great food, laugh, talk about everything under the sun, and use our brains a little bit. We all say we’d never play with anyone who doesn’t feel the same way.

3 Likes

We have a strict “no politics” rule at both my bridge and mj groups. If needed, I provide a friendly reminder.

1 Like

Oh, our mahjong group was built on political volunteers so we are planning on mimosas tomorrow!

5 Likes

I played today also. We are a very friendly group, and I’ve probably only played 6 times (days) total. I won twice - yay me. I may or may not have posted that I was worried about playing with a bigger group a couple of weeks ago. I won 3 times there. After I won once I felt like the pressure was off, and I definitely wasn’t the “worst” player, even though I’d been playing the least amount of time. I have been practicing on-line, and early on I read the Mahjong book recommended to me.
The one time I remember seeing people annoyed is when someone got up to take a phone call (that sounded unimportant). I’d heard she did that, and I think unless it’s an emergency, if you need to answer best to check that it’s not really important and then say “I’ll have to call you back.”

2 Likes

I say good for you for pushing back on an I’m sorry jar!

I play MJ, teach MJ, and manage a large group. My fourth class of a teaching session has several minutes of etiquette notes. Saying sorry or saying sorry for saying sorry is not mentioned. Punishment jars of coins are never mentioned either.

3 Likes

And where was the money going?

I’m sorry (pun intended)…but I still say…this is ridiculous.

Our group lets people answer the phone. What’s the big deal??

1 Like

Agree! People in our group occasionally excuse themselves to use the bathroom, answer the phone or place their takeout order ( we meet in the back room if a Chinese restaurant). No big deal. And no fines!

2 Likes

Playing today with one of my regular groups. One member (today’s host) texted last night asking that there be no political talk. We don’t normally talk politics, but I understand. This group is pretty easy going, we all typically bring our dogs too LOL.

I don’t agree with the ‘sorry’ rule. Although when I played on an adult women’s tennis team, it drove our coach nuts when at practice many of us would say ‘sorry’ after missing a shot.

1 Like

I was told that it would be raffled off during our Christmas party. I’ll be out of town.

Thanks for the unanimous support that I’m not wrong to say that I’m not in favor.

TBH, I think I’m going to take a break from this group until the beginning of the year. I like mahjong but I have plenty of other interests that I don’t need to feel guilty for this pushback.

6 Likes