Let's Play the College Ranking Game (Plus/Minus)

College Confidential Community
2781

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 9
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 11
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 12
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 9
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 8
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 10
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 6
Oberlin 4
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Bates +1
Bowdoin -1</p>

2782

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 9
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 11
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 9
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 8
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 10
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 6
Oberlin 3
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Claremont McKenna +1
Oberlin -1</p>

2783

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 9
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 11
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 8
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 10
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 6
Oberlin 2
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Oberlin -1
Wesleyan +1</p>

2784

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 8
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 10
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 6
Oberlin 2
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Bowdoin +1
Swarthmore -1</p>

2785

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 8
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 10
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 7
Oberlin 1
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Colgate +1
Oberlin -1</p>

2786

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 7
Oberlin 1
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Naval Academy +1
Smith -1</p>

2787

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 11
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 9
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 7
Oberlin 1
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Grinnell +1
Smith -1</p>

2788

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 11
Grinnell 9
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 7
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Carleton +1
Oberlin -1</p>

2789

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 12
Grinnell 9
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 6
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Harvey Mudd +1
Colgate -1</p>

2790

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 11
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 12
Grinnell 9
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 5
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Vassar +1
Colgate -1</p>

2791

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 12
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 11
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 5
Macalester 11</p>

<p>HMC +1
Grinnell -1</p>

2792

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 8
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 5
Macalester 11</p>

<p>Pomona +1
Vassar -1</p>

2793

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 10
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 5
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Smith +1 Macalester- 1</p>

2794

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 8
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 11
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 10
Colby 10
Colgate 4
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Wesleyan +1, Colgate -1</p>

<p>Sent from my DROID RAZR using CC</p>

2795

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 9
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 11
USMA - West Point 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 9
Colby 10
Colgate 4
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Swarthmore +1
Bates -1</p>

2796

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 10
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 11
USMA - West Point 11
USMA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 9
Colby 10
Colgate 3
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Swarthmore +1
Colgate -1</p>

2797

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 10
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 10
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 12
USMA - West Point 11
USMA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 9
Colby 10
Colgate 2
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Wesleyan +1
Colgate -1</p>

<p>Sent from my DROID RAZR using CC</p>

2798

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 10
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 11
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 12
USMA - West Point 11
USMA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 10
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 8
Smith 9
Bates 9
Colby 10
Colgate 1
Macalester 10</p>

<p>Wellesley +1
Colgate -1</p>

2799

<p>Do we really not want to restart this? This is a great idea, but in my opinion there is something obviously wrong when the colleges most students prize above all others (Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Princeton, etc.) are no longer even listed.</p>

<p>What do you think? I know someone has already suggested this, but I thought I should bring it up again.</p>

2800

<p>WavesOfFire, I understand your point. As for me, I am intrigued by the idea of a separate LAC ranking. Seeing as LAC’s and national universities are very different institutions, I think that the inclusion of Ivies and other top-tier universities would skew the results. Of course, if others agree that these other universities should be included, I digress…</p>

<p>Let’s give Hamilton some action.</p>

<p>Williams 11
Amherst 11
Swarthmore 10
Pomona 13
Middlebury 11
Bowdoin 12
Carleton 12
Wellesley 11
Claremont McKenna 13
Haverford 12
Davidson 11
Washington & Lee 11
Wesleyan 12
USMA - West Point 11
USMA - Annapolis 9
Vassar 10
Hamilton College 11
Harvey Mudd College 13
Grinnell 7
Smith 9
Bates 9
Colby 10
Colgate 1
Macalester 10</p>

<p>+Hamilton
-Grinnell</p>