Let's Play the College Ranking Game (Plus/Minus)

College Confidential Community
2841

+1 Claremont McKenna
-2 Middlebury

Middlebury 12
Claremont McKenna 15

2842

OOPS…Sorry, i forgot to copy the list…here goes:

Harvey Mudd College 15
Middlebury 12
Davidson 14
Amherst 11
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Williams 12
Swarthmore 12
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Claremont McKenna 15
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 11
Vassar 9
Hamilton College 11
Macalester 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Colby 8
Smith 6
Grinnell 4

Claremont McKenna +1
Mddlebury -2

2843

OOPS…Sorry, i forgot to copy the list…here goes:

Harvey Mudd College 15
Middlebury 13
Davidson 14
Amherst 11
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Williams 12
Swarthmore 12
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Claremont McKenna 15
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 11
Vassar 9
Hamilton College 11
Macalester 11
USNA - Annapolis 9
Colby 8
Smith 6
Grinnell 2

Middlebury +1
Grin ell -2

2844

Harvey Mudd College 15
Middlebury 13
Davidson 14
Amherst 11
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Williams 12
Swarthmore 12
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Claremont McKenna 15
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 11
Vassar 7
Hamilton College 11
Macalester 11
USNA - Annapolis 10
Colby 8
Smith 6
Grinnell 2

USNA - Annapolis +1
Vassar -2

2845

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 13
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
USNA - Annapolis 10
Colby 8
Vassar 7
Smith 6
Grinnell 0 (eliminated)

Macalester +1
Grinnell -2

2846

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 13
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
USNA - Annapolis 11
Colby 8
Smith 6
Vassar 5

USNA Annapolis +1
Vasser -2

2847

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 14
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
USNA - Annapolis 11
Colby 8
Smith 4
Vassar 5

Middlebury +1
Smith -2

2848

Let’s let OP set the rules (which have been +1/-1 for 3 years). Recomputing for recent excess subtractions:

Middlebury 16
Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
Amherst 12
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
USNA - Annapolis 11
Colby 8
Vassar 7
Smith 5
Grinnell 3

Carry On!

2849

@otisp I read most of the thread… He changed to +1/-2 in both prior games. And he’s no longer around to set new rules.

2850

@otisp - Let’s keep it at +1/-2 as the OP wanted in both prior games. Otherwise, this game will never end.

The following is based on list for #2846.

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 14
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Smith 4
Vassar 3

USMA - Annapolis +1
Vassar -2

2851

@Zinhead - In typical LAC fashion, this particular game seems less about winning or losing than, about how to make it interesting. I think that’s why it’s lasted so long. :slight_smile:

2852

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 15
Pomona 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Smith 2
Vassar 3

Middlebury +1
Smith -2

2853

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 15
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Smith 0
Vassar 3

Pomona +1
Smith -2
Oh, well.

2854

Claremont McKenna 15
Harvey Mudd College 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 15
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 15
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Vassar 3

+1 Davidson
-2 W&L

2855

Harvey Mudd College 16
Claremont McKenna 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 15
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Middlebury 15
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 9
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Vassar 3

+1 Harvey Mudd
-2 West Point

2856

Harvey Mudd College 16
Pomona 15
Davidson 15
Middlebury 15
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 9
Wellesley 11
Colby 8
Vassar 3

+1 Pomona
-2 Claremont McKenna

2857

Harvey Mudd College 16
Pomona 15
Davidson 15
Middlebury 15
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 10
Colby 8
Vassar 1

USMA - West Point +1
Vassar -2

2858

Harvey Mudd College 14
Pomona 15
Davidson 15
Middlebury 16
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 10
Colby 8
Vassar 1

Middlebury +1
Harvey Mudd -2

2859

Harvey Mudd College 14
Pomona 16
Davidson 15
Middlebury 16
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
Wellesley 11
USMA - West Point 10
Colby 8

+1 Pomona
-2 Vassar

2860

Middlebury 16
Pomona 16
Davidson 15
Harvey Mudd College 14
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Macalester 12
Swarthmore 12
Washington & Lee 10
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
USNA - Annapolis 12
Amherst 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA - West Point 11
Wellesley 9
Colby 8

USMA - West Point +1
Wellesley -2