Let's Play the College Ranking Game (Plus/Minus)

College Confidential Community
2881

Middlebury 16
Pomona 16
Davidson 15
Claremont McKenna 15
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Harvey Mudd 12
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 12
Amherst 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA- Annapolis 10
USMA- West Point 9
Colby 3
Wellesley 10
Washington & Lee 8

Harvey Mudd +1
Army -2

2882

Middlebury 16
Pomona 16
Davidson 15
Claremont McKenna 13
Harvey Mudd 15
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Swarthmore 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 13
Amherst 12
Hamilton College 11
USMA- West Point 10
USNA- Annapolis 9
Colby 3
Wellesley 10
Washington & Lee 8

Williams +1
CMC -2

2883

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Harvey Mudd 15
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Carleton 12
Swarthmore 12
Wesleyan 12
Williams 13
Amherst 12
Hamilton College 11
USMA- West Point 10
USNA- Annapolis 9
Colby 3
Wellesley 10
Washington & Lee 8

Middlebury +1
Davidson -2

2884

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Harvey Mudd 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Williams 13
Carleton 12
Swarthmore 12
Wesleyan 12
Amherst 12
Claremont McKenna 11
Hamilton College 11
USMA- West Point 10
Wellesley 10
USNA- Annapolis 9
Washington & Lee 8
Colby 3

Davidson +1
Claremont McKenna -2

2885

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Harvey Mudd 15
Davidson 14
Bowdoin 13
Haverford 13
Williams 13
Carleton 12
Swarthmore 12
Wesleyan 12
Claremont McKenna 12
Hamilton College 11
Amherst 10
USMA- West Point 10
Wellesley 10
USNA- Annapolis 9
Washington & Lee 8
Colby 3

+1 CMC
-2 Amherst

2886

@urbanslaughter Copied the wrong list
Here’s the status before my moves:

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 12
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Claremont McKenna 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
Amherst 10
USNA- Annapolis 10
USMA- West Point 9
Colby 3
Wellesley 10
Washington & Lee 8

Now I do Harvey Mudd +1 and Navy -2:

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Claremont McKenna 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
Amherst 10
USMA- West Point 9
USNA- Annapolis- 8
Colby 3
Wellesley 10
Washington & Lee 8

2887

@fprosk - Kudos for using the right list. The votes after urbanslaughter’s 11:12am post are taken from an outdated list.

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Claremont McKenna 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
Amherst 10
USMA- West Point 9
USNA- Annapolis- 9
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
Colby 3

USNA - Annapolis +1
Wellesley -2

2888

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Claremont McKenna 13
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
Amherst 8
USMA- West Point 9
USNA- Annapolis- 9
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
Colby 3

+1 CMC
-2 Amherst

2889

Middlebury 17
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7
Colby 4

West Point -2
Colby +1

2890

sorry for screwing up the list guys.

Middlebury 18
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Harvey Mudd 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7
Colby 2

Colby -2
Middlebury +1

2891

Is anyone keeping track of which schools have been eliminated so far and in what order? It would be nice to see a post of numbers 25-19.

2892

Middlebury 18
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Harvey Mudd 11
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7
Colby 3

Harvey Mudd -2
Colby +1

Eliminated so far:
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2893

Middlebury 19
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Harvey Mudd 11
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7
Colby 1

+1 Middlebury
-2 Colby

Eliminated so far:
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2894

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Harvey Mudd 11
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Wellesley 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7

+1 Middlebury
-2 Colby

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2895

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Harvey Mudd 11
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 8
Wellesley 6

USMA West Point +1
Wellesley -2

2896

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Harvey Mudd 12
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 6
Wellesley 6

+1 Harvey Mudd
-2 Army

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2897

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
Harvey Mudd 10
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 7
Wellesley 6

USMA West Point +1
Harvey Mudd -2

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2898

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Harvey Mudd 12
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 11
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
Wellesley 7
USMA West Point 4

+1 Wellesley
-2 West Point

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2899

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Harvey Mudd 12
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Hamilton College 9
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
USMA West Point 6
Wellesley 7

+1 Wellesley
-2 Hamilton

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

2900

@urbanslaughter and @Zinhead : looks like our updates overlapped. Taking all three into account:

Middlebury 20
Pomona 16
Davidson 14
Haverford 13
Swarthmore 13
Williams 13
Claremont McKenna 13
Carleton 12
Wesleyan 12
Bowdoin 11
Harvey Mudd 10
Hamilton College 9
USNA Annapolis 9
Amherst 8
Washington & Lee 8
Wellesley 8
USMA West Point 5

Eliminated so far:
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin