Let's Play the College Ranking Game (Plus/Minus)

College Confidential Community
3001

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Carleton 12
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Haverford 11
Bowdoin 10
Middlebury 7
Wesleyan 7
Wellesley 4
Washington & Lee 4

Bowdoin +1
Middlebury -2

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3002

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Haverford 11
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Middlebury 8
Wesleyan 7
Wellesley 4
Washington & Lee 4

Carleton -2
Middlebury +1

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3003

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Haverford 9
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 7
Wellesley 4
Washington & Lee 4

Haverford -2
Middlebury +1

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3004

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 8
Wellesley 4
Washington & Lee 2

Wesleyan +1
Washington & Lee -2

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3005

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 13
Williams 11
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 8
Wellesley 4

Davidson +1
Washington & Lee -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3006

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 13
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 8
Wellesley 5

Wellesley +1
Williams -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3007

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Carleton 12
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Haverford 11
Bowdoin 10
Middlebury 7
Wesleyan 5
Washington & Lee 5
Wellesley 4

Wesleyan -2
W&L +1

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3008

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Carleton 12
Davidson 12
Williams 11
Haverford 11
Bowdoin 10
Middlebury 5
Wesleyan 5
Washington & Lee 5
Wellesley 5

Middlebury -2
Wellesley +1

Eliminated so far
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3009

@Zinhead and @UWfromCA Your posts cut-and-pasted from an earlier version before W&L was eliminated. Restoring to #3005:

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 13
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 8
Wellesley 5

Wellesley +1
Williams -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3010

In that case:

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 13
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 8
Wellesley 3

Wellesley -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3011

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 11
Bowdoin 10
Carleton 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Middlebury 9
Wesleyan 9
Wellesley 3

Wesleyan +1
Davidson -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3012

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 11
Middlebury 10
Bowdoin 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Wesleyan 9
Carleton 8
Wellesley 3

Middlebury +1
Carleton -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3013

Thanks for correcting:

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Davidson 11
Bowdoin 10
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Wesleyan 9
Carleton 8
Middlebury 8
Wellesley 4

Wellesley +1
Middlebury -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3014

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Bowdoin 10
Wesleyan 10
Davidson 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Wesleyan 9
Carleton 8
Middlebury 8
Wellesley 4

Wesleyan +1
Davidson -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3015

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 14
Bowdoin 10
Wesleyan 10
Davidson 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Wesleyan 9
Carleton 8
Middlebury 8
Wellesley 2

Wellesley -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3016

Swarthmore 15
Pomona 15
Wesleyan 10
Davidson 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Wesleyan 9
Bowdoin 8
Carleton 8
Middlebury 8
Wellesley 2

Bowdoin -2
Pomona +1

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3017

Pomona 15
Swarthmore 13
Wesleyan 10
Middlebury 9
Davidson 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Bowdoin 8
Carleton 8
Wellesley 2

Middlebury +1
Swarthmore -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3018

Pomona 13
Swarthmore 13
Wesleyan 10
Davidson 10
Middlebury 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Bowdoin 8
Carleton 8
Wellesley 2

Davidson +1
Pomona -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3019

Pomona 13
Swarthmore 13
Davidson 11
Wesleyan 10
Middlebury 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Carleton 8
Bowdoin 6
Wellesley 2

Davidson +1
Bowdoin -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin

3020

Pomona 13
Swarthmore 13
Wesleyan 10
Davidson 9
Middlebury 9
Williams 9
Haverford 9
Carleton 8
Bowdoin 7
Wellesley 2

Bowdoin +1
Davidson -2

Eliminated so far
11 Washington & Lee
12 Claremont Mckenna
13 Hamilton
14 Amherst
15 Harvey Mudd
16 USNA Annapolis
17 USMA West Point
18 Colby
19 Macalester
20 Vassar
21 Smith
22 Grinnell
23 Bates
24 Colgate
25 Oberlin