Liberal arts, with non-competitive musical theater

[tsbna44]

#14 has some suggestions. Check Drew and Allegheny too.

Colleges where non-theatre majors can meaningfully participate in musical theatre productions

The other poster described it better, but this is what I was trying to explain that Michigan has. There are high level productions done through clubs and organizations, outside of the MT/drama programs. You are going to find more of those opportunities at large state schools like Purdue and Michigan.