<p>@mmmgirl, 1Rachel94:
There is an essay option for “challenging a belief/idea.” This seems to suggest that controversial topics are welcome if they show you doing critical thinking and showing other desirable character traits (e.g. maturity, intellectual honesty) to arrive at your conclusions.
For example (just an example), if you grew up in an atheistic home and then had a huge intellectual struggle that ended with you discovering the love of God, especially if this is truly the defining event of your life, I don’t see why admissions committees should have a problem with the essay just because “religion” is “controversial.” If an essay prompt asks for what your driving purpose in life is, and it’s to glorify God, is it really better to evade the truth and say something (probably true, but terribly indirect and evasive) they want to hear like “making small contributions that build up to a greater purpose”? (ignoring my bad wording)</p>
<p>That said, just because I don’t see why they should have a problem, doesn’t mean they won’t necessarily have a problem… Though I find it sort of odd(/sad) that on certain “controversial” issues, defending one side is welcomed (somewhere described an “auto-admit” for certain circumstances) while defending the other side is strictly warned against by all college advice sites.</p>