<p>My son interviewed at both, and we spent 2 days at both. I also have friends who attended both schools. I think Descartesz has an excellent characterization-I’m gonna throw in a few more stereotypical observations:
Carleton is somewhat harder to get into, and may be more rigourous. Fewer Carleton students go abroad, and I would characterize them as somewhat less activist. The campus life is more self-contained.
Mac is a happenin’ place in the middle of the twin cities, which is a fabulous place for students who don’t mind cold weather. It is very outwardly liberal and activist, and very outward looking.
At both schools faculty are awesome and helpful. Classes should be interesting, and you should learn a lot.
How would I choose? Country mouse vs. City mouse. I don’t think you can really mess up. If one is substantially cheaper for you, go there.</p>