Macalester College Visit -Thoughts

Yes, we were there as well and were very impressed by the program they put together! The campus is gorgeous, and my son was able to sit in on two classes which he found inspirational. We specifically asked a professor about the fine line between academic passion and competition and got such an honest answer it only helped us trust the institution even more. She said she has no way to know what conversations happen privately between students, but overall she described the students as passionate and motivated. In her psych classes she doesn’t have any sense of competition against (vs competition for). (IE I want to get an A, not I want to get the highest grade in the class).

That said, we’re thinking Macalester moved down a bit on our list even though his application is already in and we fell in love with the vibe (think bagpipes welcoming you into your lunch). There are fewer research opportunities than we’d like right at his fingertips. (Yes they exist in twin cities, but not the same as having a choice of different projects from a handful of different professors working on different projects). It seems there are very limited slots on campus. Also, there is no neuro department specifically, it’s a major under the bio and psych umbrella).

3 Likes

Can you elaborate on this? Are you talking about in neuro, or overall?

This is not uncommon at LACs, and is even true at some unis.

Interesting. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Much appreciated.

I believe we are looking for a unicorn in that our list includes small LACs, as well as larger research universities. Our visits are helping us weigh the balance of the benefits of small communities offering individualized support vs larger research universities in which students have multiple options just based on volume of different professors with varied academic interests. It’s possible to pursue both small communities in large universities and to find phenomenal research opportunities in small LACs it just requires balancing where one wants to put the effort!

3 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.