Seconding Clark, Wheaton MA, Suny Geneseo&New Paltz, StOlaf, Muhlenberg, Drew, UDel honors, Washington college. - some may be more likely/match than safety strictly speaking but all are a good bet for admission and merit.
If she likes Lafayette she may like Susquahanna (same vibe but less selective). UScranton is worth a visit (easy to arrange from Philly).
A bit further South, what about Roanoke?
4 Likes