Match/safety suggestions for my daughter interested in mechanical engineering or engineering des

Realize that those statistics are self reported. I have an Asian American engineer daughter. She thought long and hard before checking the ‘asian’ box on the application and on the registration material. She doesn’t (or at least didn’t at the time) identify as Asian. She just wants to be American. It didn’t matter at all for admissions.

There were other Asians in her classes, but most were not American so they wouldn’t be counted in the stats. Her school has 33% international students (most not Asian) and about 30% female with not all of those in engineering.

DS16 just graduated with a degree in EE. He applied to and was accepted at several of the big engineering schools (tOSU, Purdue, Clemson, etc) that have FY engineering/secondary admissions criteria for major. That alone creates a more competitive environment. Ultimately he chose a smaller school without those requirements and is now employed in his dream job. She really needs to get over the “settling” concept and move on to a better “fit” concept to find a true safety. The ASEE website cited above will give you stats for all programs. Focus on those that graduate a lot of women in the majors that are attractive her.

Let me help.

Reaches - Stanford, Rice, Duke
Low reaches - Berkeley, Georgia Tech, CMU, Michigan
Regular matches - Purdue, Washington, Illinois
Low matches - Colorado School of Mines, Case Western Reserve
Safeties - Washington State, Arizona State, Iowa State

Best programs:
Mechanical Engineering: Stanford, Berkeley, Georgia Tech, Michigan
Biomedical: Stanford, Georgia Tech, Rice, Duke, Washington, Michigan
Design: Stanford, CMU, Georgia Tech, Rice, Berkeley

NC State as a safety. Pretty campus. Nice weather. Raleigh. Centennial campus is new and very nice. Their Design program is well regarded.

Given the “only 18% may be OOS” limit in NC, we were told that NC State is a safety for no one—especially in engineering.

We toured NC State for S20. Was hoping son would apply but he didn’t. I’ve always liked the school and that area. Unless it’s changed in the last year they never hit the 18% OOS quota. We were told that several times on the tour and other people on CC have said the same.

That said, engineering there would probably be a match, not a safety but the Design school isn’t engineering. It’s a competitive program for admission from what I’ve heard.

But note that NCSU has a first year engineering program with a competitive secondary admission process to get into specific engineering majors later. It also does not seem to be very transparent about how competitive each specific engineering major is.

https://www.engr.ncsu.edu/academics/undergrad/coda/

Would this link be helpful?

https://www.engr.ncsu.edu/ir/coda-statistics#coda-statistics-for-engineering-degree-programs

I confess, I looked at the link for computer science and because of all the abbreviations, I found it a little confusing.

Good students should never ever fear. Let me rephrase, Good Students should not discount a program. Let’s try it differently. Good students should not worry about getting the engineering disciple they desire. Good students never get shut out! I don’t know how many other ways I can say it. Here is what secondary admissions requirements do for good students:

1> They make sure a specific discipline isn’t over subscribed. My son went to UMD for CS (not engineering, I know, but don’t tune out). UMD did not have a quota on the number of CS students they would take. If you got accepted to UMD, you could be a CS major. In fact a very large percentage did choose CS. They didn’t have the facilities nor the faculty to handle the student load. Students didn’t get many of their desired classes or professors. People who had no business teaching were teaching. UMD has since amended that process and is a decent school, but when Purdue and the like have a secondary gate they are doing it to protect good students. College is not hard if you make studying a priority. If you have a near perfect GPA and high test scores you will be successful.

2> Most people don’t really know what flavour of Engineer they will be. I suspect nearly half start out as either ME or EE and decide that ChemE or some other discipline really is interesting. That is why schools have Freshman Engineering programs, to give students a good breadth of what an engineer is. I went in all determined to be a EE, found out that IE is pretty cool. If I would have started out as an EE, I would have probably not been as successful or happy.

Yes. That’s certainly better than it was for a while, when such a thing did not appear to be present at all (or was very hard to find). Still, before that, they used to have some GPA information up that is not present now.

Guess it depends on your definition of “good student”. A student who gets admitted to UIUC pre-engineering but wants to major in bioengineering, mechanical engineering, or computer science needs to get at least a 3.75 college GPA just to be eligible to enter a competitive admission process. Why subject yourself to a weed-out process even more competitive than pre-med when you can get your major elsewhere? Reference: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/discussion/comment/22751068#Comment_22751068

Yes, UMD was late in regulating the enrollment in CS to stay within department capacity. Yes, limiting the number of students may be necessary for this purpose. But if the secondary admission threshold is very high or very competitive, that can create or intensify a “weed-out” atmosphere.

I’d suggest also reading things like USNews rankings, which has it as the #8 MechE program in the country. Or many other sources with similar opinions. My D has spent much more time studying MechE than worrying about varsity sports or other majors.

Yes a good basketball program - not sure why that’s a turnoff.

Yes, one of the top 2-3 Ag/Bio engineering programs in the country. Why would one look down on very strong programs in other areas?

Conservative - not from what I’ve seen.

1 Like

[quote=“ucbalumnus, post:70, topic:2102178”]

To be fair, UIUC does direct admit and this referenced program is a Last Chance to get into those programs, so not really a true representation of the second gate process at most engineering schools. I’d say a 3.2 is a doable GPA for most college students with a pulse who care about getting good grades.

3.2 is the auto-admit GPA for specific majors in Purdue first year engineering (note: 3.2 is probably above the median GPA in Purdue). But the thresholds vary considerably (and sometimes between majors at the same school). Some examples of different schools: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/engineering-majors/2174743-first-year-engineering-programs-secondary-admission-to-major-criteria.html

I also think that if a student is struggling to get a 3.0 in freshmen intro courses, engineering is going to be a long uphill slog as courses get harder. IMO, the secondary admission to process helps students get into majors where they can actually succeed and graduate in 4 years.

Considering that the secondary admission thresholds are generally defined by capacity, rather than a defined threshold indicating some likelihood of success, and that they vary from 2.0 to 3.75+ across various colleges and majors, that does not seem like an advantage from the student’s point of view beyond preventing enrollment from overflowing department capacity.

Also, college GPAs tend to increase at higher class levels, probably because the frosh adjustment from high school to college hits some students hard in frosh year. But that can be a disaster for those who get back on track, but are weeded out due to first semester struggles.

Tufts could be a good match for your daughter.

It offers a nationally recognized Human Factors Design major within the Mechanical Engineering Department. (The Psychology Department also offers a liberal arts variant of the degree called Engineering Psychology). It is one of the oldest such programs in the country along with MIT and Stanford. An alum of Tufts’ program (Rolf Faste - who was born in Seattle) was the director of Stanford’s design program for two decades (1984-2003). There are a couple of focus areas (medical device design and assistive design) that may be of interest to your daughter. There is some overlap between these focus areas of Human Factors Design and the Biomedical Engineering degree.

https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a5589/3491456/
https://sites.tufts.edu/humanfactors/