I agree 100% but I’m simply saying that if someone has a target cost there is zero reason to apply to any school that cannot get you there. The ‘initial’ consideration set should only include those schools so you have to eliminate schools where it’s not possible. UMD is unlikely but possible. Others not possible. That’s all I’m
saying. Hence my note to look at curriculum, call departments and see if they could work.
The OP have a target of $25k and less. So I absolutely used that as a gauntlet.
We had a target cost but are full pay. We applied to 21 including UMD. Not all got to the # I wanted. But all 20 could have. That’s what I’m suggesting OP do. They have financial safeties and they could and should throw some Hail Marys…but those should be only schools that can at least potentially, even if unlikely, make the budget.
So unless you have need or you are applying for Morehead-Cain, I see no reason to include UNC. Same for UGA (forget need aid here) although if you get a full OOS waiver it would get you close. FSU, as a sub, would put you under budget. Is their program right ? That’s what I’m saying OP should check. Florida schools, as an example, other than UF, can be cheap for this student.
This goes back to the first consideration of applying to any college is affordability.
And I agree that if one is happy with their safety, then they don’t need an expansive list. But if you are hunting for big merit, that does change the calculus and you should take your shots.
Like I said, I imagine this student will end up in state and that’s wonderful. Fine schools. Different in setting and vibe but all fine. And I might throw in Coastal too. I know less reputed in state but I think known for marine studies/science, etc.
All good.