McGill vs Oberlin vs Colby vs Hamilton vs Reed

First step is to narrow the search. These are the schools that closest to each other culturally and educational approach. All are excellent schools.

Oberlin vs Reed
Hamilton vs Colby
McGill

Then take the three finalists and eliminate one.
Based on your goals. My quick guess would be -

Oberlin
Hamilton
McGill

If you dont want the larger urban environment. And prefer the LAC size and approach.

You now have two.

Oberlin and Hamilton. Based on location and your stated goals.

Hamilton

You could end up with a different result of course. But don’t try to pick one. Use a methodology or a decision tree of sorts. It’s an easier way to process decision making.