Middlebury and Dartmouth

Note that the Parchment results for this revealed preference comparison are not in color, and are therefore not described as statistically significant.

According to D19, who is attending Middlebury, there are a fairly large number of people attending Midd who weren’t accepted at Dartmouth. So you’ll have many people with whom to commiserate.

BTW, she absolutely loves Middlebury, and, having visited Dartmouth, and met student there, she prefers Midd.

PS. She did not apply to Dartmouth.

Hello! I also applied ED to Dartmouth was deferred then rejected, and now I’m going to Middlebury this fall! I can commiserate, but after visiting both schools I was incredibly impressed with Middlebury. Similarly to Dartmouth, Middlebury has a beautiful campus with stellar academics, but a more inclusive social scene. I’m so excited to be a Midd kid, and haven’t given a second thought to Dartmouth! Go panthers!

2 Likes

Without having a full understanding of the OP’s personality, it’s impossible to tell if Midd will be a good fit. I can say that had my daughter not gotten accepted ED to Amherst, she may have well chosen Middlebury. She loved her visit there and the people she interacted with, and could see herself thriving. I’m pretty confident it was among her top three or four choices after Amherst, along with Brown, and I guess maybe Bowdoin and Swat. She didn’t plan to apply to Dartmouth, for whatever that’s worth.

I mentioned Dartmouth’s Wall Street connection to explain some (if not all) of the starting salary disparity. Other than those directly-from-undergrad-to-Wall-Street jobs, I suspect there isn’t any difference. I don’t mean to imply that you CAN’T get a job in finance from Middlebury–just that I suspect there are many more of such students at Dartmouth which will skew the numbers.

Middlebury places a fair number of people in overseas offices of major Wall Street enterprises (Goldman being among them.) I suspect their fulsome reputation in language instruction has something to do with it. This is why I think the directly-from-undergrad-to-engineering route offered at Dartmouth might be the more decisive factor.

Hey @ns10909 ! This post is going to long, but I think if you read it it may help you. Please read to the end, as you won’t really understand what I’m trying to tell yoiu otherwise.

Back when I was considering applying early to schools, I had a difficult choice to make. My dream school for two years had been Stanford. I loved so much about it, especially the amazing options in its Environmental Science program.

Dartmouth, meanwhile, had a meteoric rise on my list considering I had only learnt it existed junior year of HS. I loved a lot about it too. It was almost the equivalent of Stanford in my heart, on a list that included many other top schools.

For a number of reasons, I chose to apply to Dartmouth early instead. I was a better fit for them, I knew that. There were aspects of my background that really spoke to the Dartmouth experience (I’m a small town boy, for example), I knew that. I wanted more personal attention and small class sizes, which were easier to come by at Dartmouth, I knew that. But the one factor that clinched my decision was purely strategic – Dartmouth had a higher admission chance boost for ED relative to their RD round. So my Early app was better off at Dartmouth.

So I chose to apply to Dartmouth instead, and got in. I was happy, don’t get me wrong, but my internal attitude right after committing was to try to persuade myself it was Stanford’s equal.

And Dartmouth, on the whole, is probably the equal of or better than Stanford in. many ways (particularly for undergrads), but the constant comparison was a stupid thing to do. Even when I arrived on, campus, I was constantly seeing everything through the “Dartmouth vs Stanford” lense. Everything I did on campus in my first two quarters, I compared to Stanford.

This detached me from my undergrad experience, and now that I’m in online school due to covid, I realize how foolish I was. Constantly comparing the school I was attending to another, I failed to completely take advantage of the school I was in. I had fun, but didn’t appreciate where I was as much as I should have.

And Stanford has no relevance to me anymore, so why should I keep bringing it into every situation in my head?

So, the lesson I’d like to tell you is to STOP comparing Middlebury to Dartmouth. No doubt Middlebury is Dartmouth’s equal or better in many ways, but making comparisons isn’t going to help you.

Let me make this clear, I am NOT saying that you should accept that one is better than the other, or that that is even the case.

What I am saying is that Dartmouth isn’t relevant anymore, so push it out of your head as much as possible. Forget about it if you can.

What IS Important is for you to recognize the wonderful place you are in. Middlebury is an amazing school, and you should feel proud that you were able to get in, and lucky that you are able to go there.

Get yourself excited by it. Look at all the things you’ll be able to do at MIdd. Spent lots of time researching them, fall in love with them.

Go over to the MIdd forum on CC and ask this simple q: Get me excited about going to Midd. Don’t mention your previous dream school. Just tell them that’s where you headed, and want them to tell you why it’s amazing and how they felt about being there.

I only started using this mentality recently, and it’s transformed how I see the next three-ish years of my college experience.

I hope I helped. Please feel free to message me if you want to talk through this more.

2 Likes

In addition, to whoever mentioned Parchment, that is a demonstrably false indicator of cross admit choices. They are unverified. For demonstration, on parchment right now, WashU wins as many cross admits with Harvard as Yale does, and more than Princeton does.

You shouldn’t even look at that, it’s pure bogus.

Though Parchment appears to be unreliable for several reasons, I don’t think your examples furthered your case, @Gogreen19. Schools that offer merit scholarship recognition, like WUStL, may very well be preferred beyond common expectations in comparisons involving schools that do not. Nevertheless, the Middlebury vs. Dartmouth comparison seems to lack any value since it is not revealed in color and, therefore, even by Parchment standards, it is especially poorly supported.

I’m nominating @Gogreen19 #25 for the Post of the Year award.

Midd and Dartmouth are very similar, and there’s a lot of overlap in applicants. I say this as someone who is committed to Midd and was waitlisted by Dartmouth. Heck, even the Barstool IG page for Midd says “proving why we didn’t get into Dartmouth since (I forget the year).” I do truly believe Midd is an equally great school.

Some perks about Midd over Dartmouth

-Best of LACs instead of worst of the Ivy Leagues

Middlebury is one of the top ten LACs in the country (typically 5th to 7th) whereas Dartmouth is the second “worst” Ivy (only Cornell is lower). No one is going to question your intelligence if you attend Midd, simply because it attracts a different crowd then Harvard and other larger schools, whereas many people at Dartmouth wanted to attend an Ivy league and failed to get into a more selective one.

-Not as much of a reputation as a party school.

Although Midd certainly has parties, it has a much less pervasive party school reputation when compared to Dartmouth. This means that no matter how hard you party, when you say you attended Middlebury college, no negative assumptions will be made about you.

-No sorities or fraternities

In short, more diverse and inclusive social options.

-Less prestige whores and dicks.

So many of the people who apply to Dartmouth (especially RD) are obsessed with being able to say they attend an Ivy (my interviewer was very much like this), whereas most of the people who apply to Midd love Midd just as it is. People at Middlebury are ridiculously nice.

Honestly, Midd and Dartmouth are so insanely similar (They are the only 2 colleges in the nation to have their own ski mountains, both small and isolated, and they are in neighboring states) that one of the main reasons I chose Midd is that it embodies all the things I like about Dartmouth (small, community oriented, prestigious, language opportunities) and lacks all the things I disliked about Dartmouth (having to join a sorority/fraternity, arts aren’t accessible, not as outwardly intellectual). I’m also very satisfied with the pre-med opportunities at Midd.

I’m going to end this with something I learned from being in the ED group chat for Dartmouth. Dartmouth has a tendency to attract some of the nicest, sweetest, most caring people that I’ve ever met, and Dartmouth also has a tendency to reject them. But when they get rejected, all these applicants lose is a little bit of happiness, whereas Dartmouth loses some of its spark and glow and the chance to have a wonderful person on campus, which is a whole lot worse.

You certainly won’t be the only person on campus who also applied to Dartmouth (I’d be surprised if at least 40% of RD candidates didn’t also apply to Dartmouth), and I’m so glad you’ll be joining me at Midd!

1 Like