<p>Both schools have great reps. I repreat what others have said- a visit to each school is needed. My son chose CMU over NY for the following reasons:
Liked the curriculum at CMU- more courses (BFA wise) in theatre- NYU believes you should have more of a liberal arts background.
NYU doesn’t have it’s own theatre, I believe. They rent the theatres when needed.
CMU physical environment is newer, larger, and has more equipment.
I asked about post-graduation support systems (many colleges have set up support systems in LA and Chicago etc. w/ websites and networking opportunities for jobs. ). CMU has some, I was told NYU didn’t.</p>
<p>I am sure someone else can make an equally compelling case FOR NYU. Designers need more of a liberal arts background, don’t need your own theatre when you’re surrounded by them, equipment is rented when needed etc. and of course: location, location, location…</p>
<p>I love the fact that each college is different. There’s no one-size-fits-all mentality!</p>