Every person is different but it’s unlikely for most of us to walk through a river of diversity and come out dry. We tend to learn and grow.
You are right about many schools on this list being STEM heavy. Those schools tend to give academic achievement more weight in admissions to make sure their admitted students are able to handle academic rigor.
They only include a small subset of all 4000+ colleges. If I include all 4-year colleges that offer bachelor’s degrees, I get the following “most diverse” colleges with the described methodology. I am excluding unknowns ethnicity, as if they are not a part of the campus population. The list from the OP is often ~1% off from my calculation, perhaps because of treating unknowns differently and/or using different years.
Note that the top 3 are all Hawaiian universities. A maximum score of 7/8 = 87.5% would occur with equal distribution among all 8 race/ethnicity categories. The top ranked college reached 83% with~21% Hawaiian, ~19% Asian, ~19% Black, ~14% White, ~14% Hispanic, and ~12% Multi-racial. The main areas they were lacking are American Indian and international.
University of Phoenix-Hawaii -- 83%
Pacific Rim Christian -- 82%
Hawaii Pacific U -- 82%
Westcliff U -- 81%
NYIT -- 80% (list says 81%)
The highest Ivy was Columbia at 77% (list says 78%). The lowest Ivy was Dartmouth at 69%. The least diverse college that I’ve seen mentioned on the forums is Morehouse at 8% (94% black).