Beloit is strong on the intellectual side. It’s a college where it’s ok to be a thinker, and to have one’s own ideas. I know a few academics who earned their undergraduate degrees from Beloit. It would be less reachy than some colleges the OP is visiting but it has the intellectual core that most of the best schools strive for.
ADDED: this is not a reach for this applicant. Her current scores and grades are well within the range of the recently admitted students. I think Beloit looks for students with interest, motivation, spark AND ability, but not kids who are fixated on the numbers. Take a look at the CDS: https://www.beloit.edu/irap/collegedata/cds/