I am pretty much in agreement with everyone else. I would not worry about it. I would let it go. However, I also would be THRILLED that your son has sensible and realistic expectations for universities to attend.
If the top universities have any difference at all wrt academics, the biggest difference is probably that some of them (MIT comes to mind) are more demanding and more stressful than other schools. No student should go to the most stressful school possible unless they want to do it. Just being a student with straight A’s throughout high school doesn’t mean that MIT or Caltech or Harvard would be a good fit.
I will also note that when I was a graduate student at a very selective university, there were other graduate students there who had done undergrad all over the place. I didn’t happen to know anyone from Ohio, but I did know several very strong students who had done their undergrad at an in-state public university that is ranked very slightly lower than Ohio State.
FAFSA EFC does not include primary home equity. Some private schools require CSS profile and might figure in your home equity as well. So the EFC there might be higher.
Run the net price calculator at school websites and see how much you would be required to pay.
Case is probably $30k or more. Even with merit. But it’s free to apply so worth a shot.
Merit at Pitt with 34 ACT is possible, but not guaranteed. Merit deadline is December 15th.
Those schools you listed on his list are fine. OSU has a very good pharmacy school if he wants to pursue that. At instate prices. But he will need a bachelor’s degree there first anyway, so going somewhere else for undergrad and exploring interests is also fine.
He could add Duquesne to his list, he might get quite a bit of merit there.
Or U Scranton. Temple has a pharmacy school (3+4 program), and good business school too. He has a chance at merit there too.
WVU might be another good option.
But he will also be fine with the instate schools. And you will have more money at retirement and he will not be saddled with debt.
Sounds like you’ve gotten great advice. He has plenty of good choices and can look into honor programs if he wants to go that direction. If you are thinking of asking him to apply elsewhere, I would run the NPC’s to be sure they are within range. He seems happy with his choices and if it were my son, I wouldn’t want to cause undue stress/angst by applying somewhere we ultimately couldn’t afford.
All of the schools you listed are great schools. As far as business schools Ohio State (Fisher) is or has been ranked 14. Miami if Ohio (Farmer) is or has been ranked 40.
Don’t know if anyone still cares but this may provide closure
If you have ever heard of the Big Fish Little Pond Theory, it is a fascinating idea that highly talented students perform better at schools that may not exactly be schools filled with highly talented students. If you wish to learn more here’s a link to a video describing that backs the argument with studies and facts.
My S finally decided to go to Miami. Applied to ND, and was declined. Waitlisted at Case, and had mixed feelings about the place anyway, so he decided not to persevere. Liked U of Cincinnati, but merit offer was very weak, and he had reservations about the quality of the program compared to Miami’s. Admitted to OSU with Maximus, but wasn’t interested in even visiting; I think the size was a turn-off (and maybe the spectator sports culture, too. He’s not into that). Finally, he simply wasn’t interested in going farther than about 250 miles for college, so that ruled out all the Eastern schools that might have been otherwise good options.
Miami is a very solid school and he has a good merit award, and is looking forward to the experience. I’m fine with his decision.