The conversation after this post went a little sideways, though @YoLo2 has brought it back on track. If you’re trying to use the ED acceptance rate as a proxy for overall selectivity, it’s a really messy measure, because it’s confounded by a bunch of factors (including recruited athletic applicants) - better to look at other data like GPA and test scores, and do some comparisons with other schools you’re looking at. (It looks to have higher standards for admissions than Wittenberg, for example.)
As noted by @YoLo2, with only a couple of prominent exceptions, ED acceptance rates for committed athletes are ~100%, minus strange edge cases (self-inflicted shenanigans, miscommunications, etc.) That’s the deal.