Nerdy Black Girl Biochemistry major- where to go?

Both the Chancellor’s Science Scholars and Howard’s Bison STEM Scholars are modeled after UMBC’s Meyerhoff Scholars. Howard wants to challenge UMBC’s role of producing the most black STEM PhDs and MDs.

UNC also has one of the top School of Public Health (Gillings) and School of Social Work (Jordan, as in MJ :slight_smile: in the country so that’s an added bonus for OP’s daughter given her interests. Okay, I’ll stop now! :slight_smile:

I’d encourage her to visit Bryn Mawr in addition to Swarthmore.

I’m biased, but I think your daughter would fit into Harvard despite your qualms, and I’d encourage her to apply. One of my middle school classmates was a black female who ended up attending with me and she loved it and thrived.

https://college.harvard.edu/admissions/admissions-statistics

15% African American, 51% white.

“I pushed her to visit Stanford, Yale and Vassar.”

How did she like those visits? If she didn’t feel like a fit at those places, that would tell you something.

Harvard includes multi-racial in their African American percentage, which makes the number look much higher.

Well, everyone else is suggesting expensive, need-based aid schools, so here goes: Take a look at Wesleyan (CT); it’s a little larger than Williams (~3000 students) and labors in the same vineyard as Amherst, Middlebury and other small New England colleges. It is only one of two in its athletic conference that awards doctoral degrees in STEM (the other being Tufts) which gives it a leg up when it comes to tax-supported government grants. Undergraduate research abounds http://newsletter.blogs.wesleyan.edu/2017/05/05/students-present-academic-research-at-several-poster-sessions/
and is balanced by an eye-popping number of alumni who go into the visual and performing arts (Lin-Manuel Miranda is one of them.)

About 10% of the incoming class is Black and that has been fairly consistent ever since the late 1960s, an unusually long time for an elite eastern college. I would describe the social climate as cosmopolitan, with many students actively engaged in passionate pursuits outside the classroom be it filmmaking, theater, politics, or athletics. No one group predominates; a self-described “nerd” with an affinity for STEM would have no trouble finding their peep.

Other colleges and universities with a similar feel and vibe would include Brown, Vassar, Tufts and Barnard.

OP, hope you will continue posting as our daughters’ wish lists are very similar (biochem w/ liberal arts, economic and racial diversity, near a city, etc.). Would be fun to compare notes along the journey.

Her guidance counselors are recommending she look at Rice and Emory, but like your daughter, she’s been reluctant to consider the South. UNC was never under serious consideration, but became an automatic no after their poor reaction to the toppling of “Silent Sam.” U of Rochester sounds like a fantastic fit for her on paper, but from what we’ve read they’re having a tough time combating racism on campus. Rooting for them to get it figured out, but in the meantime we’ll pass.

She had similar reservations about Missouri, but we’ve read enough positive things about WUSTL and their efforts to increase diversity that she applied for their preview program and will be attending in a few weeks. Also considering applying to Case Western’s, but their percentage of URMs would be the lowest on her list.

She plans to apply to Smith, Vassar and Barnard, but knows going in that the financials may not work out in her favor.

Best of luck to your daughter! Sounds like she has a bright future wherever she ends up.

I find the focus on WashU strange. Just a few years ago they were identified as having the lowest number of Pell grant recipients in the country. More recently, the NYT 2017 graph below shows them with 21% of their students from the top 1% economically and only 6% from the ENTIRE bottom 60 percent. They were the worst performing college in the country!!

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/18/upshot/some-colleges-have-more-students-from-the-top-1-percent-than-the-bottom-60.html

While I realize economic diversity is not the same as racial diversity, I still find that kind of wealth on campus as the opposite of the non-elite vibe that the OP mentioned her daughter is looking for.

With respect to Silent Sam at UNC, granted it was a mess but I can assure you the administration is very glad he’s down. He will be shuttled to a far, ignominious corner of campus. He should have come down sooner, but the chancellor felt hamstrung (rightly or wrongly) by a state law. The students led the way, thankfully!

Doesn’t seem strange to me. If you’re an upper middle class, science-focused URM with top stats, then a highly ranked university that offers merit-based aid specifically targeted to URMs will eventually show up on your radar. (It’s not as if there’s an abundance of them!) Whether it’s economically diverse “enough” is an open question. That’s why they have the preview program, I imagine, so that students can check it out and decide for themselves how comfortable they’d be in that environment.

WashU definitely has strong elitist vibes. I would not have sent my upper middle class URM there. I know one there now who was shut out of a popular club because her background wasn’t “quite right.”

@Curiosa - WashU has a hill to climb to grow its economic diversity, but point well taken that it’s ultimately a student’s personal assessment and decision about fit.

With your D being both an outstanding student and URM, she is a competitive applicant for any college. I also think she would be a competitive applicant for some excellent merit scholarships as well.

My D and I toured extensively in 2016 when she applied. One college she loved was Vanderbilt. Yes, it is in the South, but as a non-white family, my D and I both found it very welcoming, and other students we know from our high school agree. It is 12.4% Black, and minorities make up 45% of the student population. She would also be eligible for the Vanderbilt scholarships, some of which are full tuition.

Plenty of people have already recommended Rice, which always competes with Vanderbilt for happiest students, and has one of the most attractive college campuses in existence. I don’t know if anyone has mentioned the Texas Medical Center, the world’s largest medical complex, which is literally across the street from Rice and has abundant research opportunities if that interests here.

A final college to consider is Duke, which I didn’t see with my D, but will likely see with S next year when he applies. It does have a very different vibe from the other two, which you have to consider, but the academics are top-notch and they also dangle some full-ride merit scholarships as well.

Before anyone says it, yes these are all reaches and you should make sure that your D has matches and safeties. Note however that Vanderbilt traditionally has been very predictable in terms of who they admit according to GPA and SAT scores. Your D’s scores are firmly in the “green zone” so it might best be considered a “high match”. Also note that “demonstrated interest” matters to all three of these colleges unlike say

Your D has done well and is an attractive applicant. Congrats to her.

@Curiosa and @crankylibrarian Don’t count out Rochester because of talk of racism. I know of racial incidents from years ago but haven’t heard of any since my daughter started there in 2015. Much of the recent news coverage, especially in response to the “We’re Better Than That” campaign is part of a wider—and important—discussion of the structural racism that is a pervasive element in American society, including the UR campus. I also expect that new leadership will result in an administration that is more proactive than was true in the past in terms of dealing with issues of all kinds as they come up.

Rochester needs more “nerdy black girls (and guys)” (to steal the OP’s description). And I think students, staff, professors, and administration would agree. It’s a great campus full of students who are bright, hardworking, inclusive, and, yes, nerdy. The academic environment is rigorous but cooperative. And, they can be quite generous with merit aid for the right candidate.

I am overwhelmed and humbled by all the help I’ve received. You folks are the best! Definitely taking another look at Wash U, Emory, Rice and Johns Hopkins. I think Pomona might be a better fit than HM, but she would still be able to take classes there.

Question for the Howard parent: I’m concerned about the financial aid scandal. I know it’s not likely we would get much, but I don’t want her to get in a situation where we are paying more than expected.

I grew up a block from Stony Island! Very helpful to hear your take on WUSL.

Also re John Hopkins and WUSTL, they have a lot of frats and sororities, which we would prefer to avoid. Rice doesn’t though!

Well Vanderbilt is big on Greek life, so that is something to consider. But of the two kids I know there, one is not Greek but is also very happy.

Also, it sounds like you lived near UChicago? I didn’t see that on your list. My D is there and loves it. Feel free to PM me about that or anything else I have mentioned.

@crankylibrarian Howard Parent back. The financial scandal (Actual audit results sent by Howard showed 369K stolen from 2011-2016 from an University with a 800 million dollar yearly budget along with 6 employees fired) has had 2 major effects that I can see so far. The University has added a lot of staff including extra levels of compliance to address the concerns found after the audit. Howard’s bigger concern deals with the Department of Education changing their status for monitoring Howard’s financial transactions. I will post a part of the letter below:

“This change in status means that all drawdowns for Title IV funds will require the University to submit all documentation on each student before the Department of Education will release the funds. This documentation must be accurate and complete to ensure reimbursement”.

This means that government funds will not be dispersed until all financial aid paperwork is accurately completed and turned in. Before the scandal, they could report the amount and the funds would be on the way which means that government financial aid will be slowed but Howard is promising to fill the gap. Students with your daughter’s stats will get a large merit package regardless (My daughter was initially offered about 27K in merit and 18K in loans), and if she went after the Bison Stem Scholarship (competitive, but your daughter would be at the top statistically for the 25-30 students selected) could get a full ride scholarship for students interested in getting PhD and MD/PhD’s in STEM majors (1/4 tuition family contribution for families with 150K or higher income). You sound close to the scholarship income limit for a family contribution like we are, but I just upped my retirement savings to make sure we stayed under the income threshold. My daughter gets no government financial aid/loans so she has not been affected at all. I have attached a link on CC where I go through the process for getting the scholarship.

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/howard-university/2067549-howard-university-bison-stem-scholars-program-bssp.html#latest

If you have any other questions, feel free to PM me, as your daughter would probably be of great interest to the Bison STEM Scholars Director.

Emory has a pretty large Greek scene too. My daughter is white, but she did not want to go to a school that had a predominant Greek scene. One of the main reasons she chose Rice was its inclusive residential college system. Each student is assigned to a residential college where the student lives all 4 years unless they are living off campus. The residential colleges have strong rivalries with each other all In good fun. Each residential college is a microcosm of the university with a mixture of races, athletes and non athletes, students pursuing various majors, etc. My daughter narrowed it down to a choice between Rice and Emory and chose Rice because of the residential college system. If you have any questions about Rice feel free to PM me. https://dou.rice.edu/residential-colleges