I’m guessing there’s a weighting system for each metric.
Fairfield has 3 As (all A-) and 3 Bs (a B+, B, and B-) on the cover page.
Fordham has one A (diversity), 4 Bs (2 B+, 1 B and 1 B-) and a C+.
So if the academic rank was solely looked at (which they got a B+, the rank might look different).
Here are the weightings - as usual, it’s always in the methodology - and some always disagree.