<p>We had the opposite problem, which you see very little about on this site. My daughter is a senior at a very strong catholic high school that routinely sends a few girls to Ivys and Cal and Stanford and so on, and she has about a 3.8 gpa, unweighted. Her SATs (after 2 tries) are about 1500/2400, and ACT the equivalent. We have never been able to get to the bottom of her low test scores. It worked out OK, and she got into the exact college she wanted (fortunately, she is a recruited athlete) but had it not been for that, I don’t know what we would have done. She was another one who didn’t really match any of the points on Naviance. I wonder why this never comes up on this board?</p>