<p>abcde,
In the opening to your post, you seem to suggest that majoring in something that is not practical in today’s economy is a poor choice. Do you suggest nobody ever major in music, theater, film, English, or history, for example? I don’t see one’s major as the determinator of one’s possible career or job opportunities. One goes to college to become educated. They major in something that is an interest area. It doesn’t mean that is the only thing they will ever be able to do in terms of a career. Besides that, if nobody majored in these areas, who would then become tomorrow’s artists, writers, etc.? </p>
<p>You also go on to say that anyone can learn to do filmmaking and they don’t need an expensive college program to do it. While that may be true, a college degree often serves one well in life. It can open more doors. Besides, an educated mind is a good thing. </p>
<p>You also say one shouldn’t bother with film school or this type of degree program if they don’t have the talent or what it takes to make it. Well, these programs, such as at Tisch, are extremely selective and competitive for admission and the schools do weigh the artistic talent of the applicants. This is no guarantee that those admitted will eventually be successful in the field, but it is a “cut” of sorts of those who may have the potential to make it. There is a talent cut off at the point of college admission to such selective programs.</p>
<p>I’m not advocating debt, and no matter the major, I am not one who favors students going into much debt (a little perhaps). I am of the value system that education is something one provides for their offspring. But one thing I am not into is tying this debt issue to the college major. I think the debt issue is one for most people, no matter the major. </p>
<p>I, like many parents participating on this Musical Theater Majors forum, fully support my kid majoring in the arts and pursuing it as a career. Paying for her to attend NYU/Tisch was worth it to us and that was our feeling before she even graduated and is earning her living now in this field. I feel we paid for her education, and not simply job training. </p>