What’s your budget?
What’s the net cost at each?
I’d go with U Toronto personally, since they’ve got such a stellar reputation in your field and gave you a scholarship.
If you’re admitted to UCLA or UT we may revisit, but as of now, UToronto> NYU in every aspect you mentioned, thanks to 1° great city 2° collegiate university 3° reputation/academic quality 4° Canadian policy toward internationals (assuming you’d be international both in Canada and the US. if you’re American, let us know as it might change things a bit).