The first “real” professional play I saw was My Fair Lady on the West End in London as a teenager. I was mesmerized.Next professional play I can remember seeing was Camelot with a way too old Robert Goulet at the Jordan School of Music in Indianapolis.
I really fell in love with theatre in college seeing lots of productions at Trinity Rep. The one I remember most was Lovecraft’s Follies.
Later I moved in NYC and for a lot of years went to London at least twice a year for theatre.
Among the truly amazing performances I saw during that time frame were
Othello at the National Theatre (UK) with Paul Scofield, whom I consider one of the greatest if not the greatest Shakespearean actor of the 2oth century, and Felicity Kendall, Michael Gambon, Penelope Wilton, and others.
The Royal Shakespeare Company’s Othello starring Ben Kingsley.
Scofield in Volpone with John Gielgud.
Lettice and Lovage with Maggie Smith and Margaret Tyzack.
First Monday In October with Henry Fonda and Jane Alexander.
On the 20th Century with Kevin Kline.
I don’t remember any particular star, but Les Mis blew me away the first time I saw it.
Then post-divorce I saw a lot less theatre, but I did see Rent and Cherry Jones in Doubt, both of which I liked.
A few years ago I got back into theatre. However, I see very little B’way–it’s just too expensive, though I do splurge on lottery tickets once in a while and, very rarely, I get to be “paper” at a Broadway show. I see about 60 Off-Broadway and Off-Off Broadway a year, almost always as “paper,” which runs me about $375 or so a year.
Among my favorite Off and Off-Off B’way shows or performances in recent years are Figaro (90210); Michael Urie in The Government Inspector; Mairin Ireland in Summer and Smoke–the play isn’t that great, but Ireland was excellent; White Guy On the Bus with Robert Cuccioli and The State of the Union, a revival of a 1947 play.
It’s amazing how much real good theatre there is in New York, even if you’re on a budget.