One of the best books I've read in the last 6 months is .

Suburban Nation: The Rise of Sprawl and the Decline of the American Dream by Andres Duany, Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, and Jeff Speck.

Didn’t end up loving The Girl on the Train.

bookmama, I’m reading that now and agree with you. We have several mutual friends in the NY theatre world and I’ve had the pleasure of meeting him several times. He’s a nice man, and a very talented actor.

I succumbed to hype, purchased ā€œThe Girl on The Trainā€ for my e-reader…and am stalled halfway through. Eh, doesn’t seem that special to me. I will probably go back and finish it, but I am distracted by the much better written and engaging ā€œHerā€ by Harriet Lane. Her first book, ā€œAlys, Alwaysā€ was a favorite and this one is even better.

alwaysamom, I love him on The Good Wife and I saw him in the first revival of Cabaret and I have tickets to see again with him and Emma Stone.

I won it and gave it 2 and a half stars, which for me is a really low rating. Different strokes for different folks.

Indeed.

I’m feeling under the weather and I’m looking for book suggestions. Criteria are warm, engaging, well-written but not too taxing. Romantic would be nice. In short, I’m seeking suggestions for the literary equivalent of comfort food.

My go-to chicken-soup books are Room with a View and Jane Eyre – the perfect books to wallow in when you’re sick. Any suggestions? Maybe something off the beaten path? Can be contemporary or classic (less well-known classics).

(Not looking for fantasy, sci fi, dystopian, or books set during WWII right now. Just not in the mood).

Grabbed 'The Girl on a Train" off the 7 day hot pick shelf at the library this morning and am already over 100 pages in. Loving it so far…

Well..not at all romantic, but I loved ā€œThe Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie,ā€ which was recommended earlier on this thread. I devoured 3 more books about the same character. I recommended it to a very close friend, who has read all of the published ones. She loves them even more than I do.

It’s sort of a cross between ā€œMiss Marpleā€ stories and ā€œHarriet the Spyā€ with a dash of PG Wodehouse’s Jeeves. Eleven year old girl who is precociously good at chemistry solves murders in a small English village circa 1955. Very, very astute observations about human relationships, which is an area of life in which our ā€œheroineā€ is not at all precocious.

Most of Alexander McCall Smith’s books fall into the comfort food category too. I especially like the 44 Scotland Street series. http://www.alexandermccallsmith.co.uk/books/ He’s more famous for the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency series, though. I enjoy those too.

If you are in a classical mood, have you read Jane Austen’s ā€œPersuasion?ā€ Less famous that Pride and Prejudice, Sense and Sensibility, and Emma.

Yes, exactly, those are all excellent suggestions and exactly what I am looking for – but I’ve read them all. Love Flavia de Luce! Got a bit tired of the McCall Smith books, but that’s exactly the mood. Persuasion is one of my all-time favorite books – just re-read it about a year ago when I was sick.

Maybe I will re-read Mansfield Park. I suppose it is too much of a fantasy to hope that someone will know of a Jane Austen equivalent that somehow flew under the radar?

I just thought of another book that falls in this category of literary comfort food: I Captured the Castle by Dodie Smith.

I just reread one of my all-time favorites, Handling Sin by Michael Malone. Charming, picaresque story with hilarious setpieces heading toward a very moving ending. Thoroughly enjoyable.

Ooh, never heard of it! Thanks! I will check it out!

@nottelling: Longborn, by Jo Baker. A ā€˜retelling’ of Pride and Prejudice from downstairs. Much better than most other fake P&P ā€˜sequels’.

Circle of Friends, Maeve Binchy? Sometimes I reread that when I just want to sit around and sob, lol.

@nottelling, have you read Still Alice?

It’s really wonderful.

@notelling I really like Penelope Lively, but I’m not sure they give you enough of a happy ending to be satisfied. Have you read Neville Shute? I love *A Town Like Alice *, but his other books are fun too. Somebody on NPR was talking about *The Thornbirds * and I was almost tempted to reread it.

I’m getting some good ideas for my next book. Almost at the end of Girl on a Train and I’m still enjoying it. I know it’s being compared to Gone Girl but I like Girl on a Train much better.

A new Flavia book was just released in the last couple of weeks, have you read that one yet? I haven’t gotten to it yet. But just in case you didn’t know. :slight_smile: I also love ā€œI Capture the Castleā€!

@nottelling. Language of a Flowers?

Euphoria by Lily King.