I just finished reading “Ardennes 1944” by Anthony Beevor, about the Battle of the Bulge. I thought I knew something about it (my dad fought in that as part of the 3rd Army, was part of the Bastogne relief column), but it opened my eyes to a lot of things and in some ways differs from the standard accounts, for example the impression generally given is that Bastogne was in desperate shape when Patton “rescued” it, when they had it pretty well secured, and when the Germans demanded that McAuliffe surrender, even they knew it was ridiculous, among other things the Germans didn’t have enough troops or tanks at Bastogne to hope of taking it, McCauliffe knew that too.
What made the book more vivid to me is the profiles of the people involved, it wasn’t too friendly towards Bradley, whom they paint as being out of touch, Montgomery single handedly nearly broke up the alliance (the book argues he comes off as being kind of high functioning autistic), but it also paints the sheer misery of it, the stupidity, the waste, along with the bravery and more than a few acts of humanity in a brutal, brutal time and place. It talks a lot about the massacre at Malmedy and how that changed the tenor of the fighting (among other things, it may have actually lengthened the fighting, the German soldiers, when they heard what happened, were afraid, not without reason, that the US soldiers may not be taking prisoners). People who think war is full of black and white, good and bad guys might be surprised at this, like how in the end many of those responsible for unbelievable atrocities ended up not paying much of a price for it, including the person responsible for Malmedy and many atrocities against civilians, who ended up getting off pretty scott free because of the efforts of certain politicians in the US who clamored that he and the others were not given fair trials, etc (the guy responsible for Malmedy did finally get some kind of justice, he was living in France in the 70’s, and ex members of the French resistance tracked him down and killed him).
Overall, it is a book I wish people who still see war as something to be glorified would read, it isn’t that war isn’t necessary at times, it is, but it also shows the real horrors and costs of it, it also explains a lot to me of why my father was so anti military, when you read about the stupidity, the unwillingness to listen to reason and how many were killed for no reason whatsoever, it makes sense.