There is no reason for PT to come to an end if it is medically beneficial. If he needs PT to stand on his own, Medicare will cover it. My neighbor gets his from a therapist who comes to his house. My MIL has been getting PT continuously since July 2025, and it has allowed her to keep up her strength so that she can transition from her wheelchair by herself.
Well actually PT ended a while back. OT and PT have both been able to justify renewal many times, and once PT ended OT started including helpful walks. Not sure on the details because wife does not share much. (But I do know she advocates strongly for any services that are free). And Dad can’t hear me on the phone… on our calls, mostly I just listen.
Yay, sounds like Dad’s wife has been able to arrange some more in-home PT. Hope it works out.
Any insight into why there seems to be such digging on their heels on honestly any provision to help? Or changing literally anything?
I felt that there had to be a huge negotiation for my mil to install a handrail on their front steps? She seems to be resistant to any suggestions to make her life easier. She keeps telling my husband she knows she should move to independent living, the next sentence is how she’s doing fine living alone. Doesn’t he agree that she’s smart? Does he want to see her scores on her nursing boards? These are the conversations he is having with her.
My husband was helping a friend and there seems to be no acknowledgment that things have changed. My husband made a suggestion to make their life easier and the wife looked at him like he had a 3rd head.
Now the husband is not going to be able to get out because it’s physically impossible. They don’t seem to want to make any adjustments. So now there is an aspect of any social life that is going to dry up.
Is it generational? Is it part of aging? Is there a fear of changing anything?
Can you tell that my greatest fear is that I’m going to turn into the same denialist? ![]()
IMHO there not only is resistance to change, but an idea that they can selectively direct and control many aspects that are not controllable, just things that need to be dealt with - better ahead of the curve than behind it.
In some ways, more important to go out on a limb for parents; otherwise there is a ‘pecking order’ and no need to take extra wrath from others that are not receptive to ‘real help’.
If the mother needs a handrail, make arrangements for it to get installed. Sometimes encouraging that S/DIL would feel terrible if there was a convenience overlooked and something bad happened. Also, maybe she can direct the details on ‘living fine alone’ so Son can have assurances on her being fine. Communication is so important, but she may fear communicating because she wants to keep up an illusion.
What I’m seeing in my our family with the elders is that routine is really important. Even small changes are hard to adapt to, let alone big things, like moving to a CCRC. In our experience, family needed to do more than just suggest but really be upfront with the dangers of remaining in the house, get some buy in, and then forge ahead with the plan. FWIW, the fact that MIL is saying she should move is already a step in the right direction. Your H can just get her to take the next step which is doing a tour. I’d also play into the “don’t you think I’m smart” comment. Yes, I do! Which is why I know that you’ll make the right decisions and start the moving process. Moving to a community is the smart thing to do!
There was insistence that there needed to be a handrail. I showed her some and she picked what was least offensive
As far as moving, that feels like lip service. She won’t let her kids take her on a tour, she will ask her neighbor. But she doesn’t. Tons of excuses. Spring, she was told not to do anything for a year after fil passed away. It’s a litany, plus years of teaching her boys that she is competent and in command.
TBH that’s their problem and not mine. But it’s so interesting that I see it with other elders so this isn’t specific to her
Definitely seems to be a universal problem!
The other thing we see is that my mil no longer listens. She talks at you. She was never a good listener, now she doesn’t even pretend to
We see that in our family too! And they don’t really initiate any of the contact any more. It’s always us reaching out and then just listening to the soliloquies. Some of the family are taking that personally and interpreting that as the senior doesn’t care about what’s going on in our lives, but we’ve found that if we just share what’s going on without being prompted, there is still appreciation for being kept in the loop. But yes, being talked at is thing for us too.
FWIW, It took YEARS from the beginning of the conversations to actually getting something done, across the board, for all our elderly family members. And from their perspectives, we “rushed them,” “made them,” and gave “no notice”. Nothing could have been further from the truth but that was the perception and what was being told to friends.
@deb922 - You are not alone!
For sure. My friend’s in laws refuse to move. They are in their 90’s, and they live 45 minutes from a grocery store - even farther from family. Her MIL had her leg amputated at the hip years ago, and she is in a wheelchair. They should not be in their current living situation anymore, but they absolutely refuse to make any changes. My friend feels really bad for her FIL, who has to do all the work, and who would like to move to a different situation, closer to family.
Although my in laws did move into AL in their 90’s, they should have moved sooner. MIL refused to allow ramps, handrails or the removal of throw rugs … what would people think? FIL fell and broke his hip because of her hard headedness.
All we can do is hope to make better decisions when our time comes.
There are a bunch of factors I think driving their behavior as they age. The first is that personality traits seem to get stronger, your mom who was a little bit mean may become very mean. The second is that they become stubborn and will not listen to any opposing view, they truly feel that their long life of experience has made them correct about all things. Thirdly, they don’t want to accept that they have changed and therefore their life needs to change. I totally get this last one, hey I don’t want to accept that I now have an arthritic knee at 65 and can’t climb 7 flights of steps a day like I used to.
My bff is a therapist and she once told me that my mother’s immediate negative responses were a way to keep control while trying to gain equilibrium. Good news, bad news didn’t matter. She’d say no as a way to shut down conversation. I think the situation is pretty universal.
Add to that the fact that change is scary and they likely know that changing their living arrangement significantly means that they can no longer use their routines/familiarity with their home to hide their deficiencies. People often think that moving “caused” a decline when the truth may be that the decline always was there but was masked and now the person’s cognitive/physical limitations was there for everyone to see.
After watching many elders in my life, and those I know socially, I think it is part of aging to wait too long to make changes. Just like other body parts, brains stop working well and I think sound judgement is one of the first victims. Because isn’t the hallmark a complete inability to be reasoned with? FIL literally denies there’s any reason to worry. MIL says it’s “not their problem” to think about. They won’t even tell us where their will is. They are 85.
My inlaws are less and less mobile, in a open plan contemporary isolated from neighbors with stairs everywhere. FIL has multiple ongoing health concerns but is shopping doctors to find one who will do a laminectomy (nobody is gonna do that). They cannot use cell phones reliably, social media, or computers. They have a magic jack landline that works intermittantly. Their main contact is my BIL via an Alexa. He works 2 hrs away.
Țhere is no avoiding the coming catastrophe, no matter what form it takes. BIL is largely naive about how this will go, has no real money sense and a disabled wife. DH has thrown up his hands in frustration.
My takeaway is that we will move in our middle/late 70’s, NO MATTER WHAT. Because even here, I see people saying “I can stay in my house until I need to move” or " my kids can help with yard care" etc. People, c’mon. Being proactive even when it seems unnecessary is going to save money, time, and sanity. Otherwise we are just perpetuating the problem.
Who upthread said they are giving a letter to their kids and that when they both give them back it’s time for a change? I love and am stealing that idea.
Should we notorized the letters? Just kidding around (based on discussions in other threads). Though perhaps it would not hurt, in case turn into the dubious elderly parent that I hope not to be.
My sister and I were shocked and sad to learn that my father’s palliative care program is “on hold” with the local Hospice organization. Maybe(?) it will restart in 2027 but my guess is financial challenges will cause to prioritize only Medicare-reimbursed services. Sigh. Too bad because the home-visit palliative care doctor had established a really good relationship with my father and is wife. I happened to be visiting earlier this year when Dr came by for a visit.
When I called the office and got the bad news (wife only told me Dr was a “no show” - perhaps she missed the letter sent out)…., office said client/family can arrange Hospice evaluation. Still feels too early to do so, but I will think on ways to broach the subject.
Thanks for your post. It gives me some insight to what might be going on with my MIL. She tells everyone no to any offers of assistance. She also shuts down any conversation pretty quick if it involves their health. I know she is tired and it’s hard for her to handle all the things she feels are now her responsibility as her spouse is less able. They are a generation where the husband took care of everything. I know she has a lot of fear.
She hesitates on any new medical issue or follow up suggestions from their doctor as she doesn’t want more doctor appointments.
I agree @Youdon_tsay. Your post is very helpful.
My mil is experiencing change and is not reacting well to it. It’s been very noticeable.
Also I appreciate you pointing out that the familiarity of a house you’ve been in for a long time could mask decline.
I was having lunch with a few friends who are pushing 80. They do not want to think about aging or that they will have to think about the future. It’s definitely head in sand! I feel bad that sometimes I mention my own mortality.
Like I’m doing a remodel now at 64 because I don’t have decades to live here. I will have to move near my far away children at some point. But please lord, can they move to an affordable and easy to navigate place! ![]()
If the patient fits hospice criteria, they can be in hospice … it’s not the “limited time left” thing that many believe it to be. MIL has been in hospice for years, because she has congestive heart failure & has almost died several times. She’s not going to not have CHF, so as long as the hospice doesn’t get tired of working with her, she can stay with it (and she can always switch to another if there’s an issue). The hospice she has been with for the past 16 months has actually made her life so much better (better being relative for a 99 year old with CHF, of course). The key is to understand what hospice can be, rather than as strictly an end of life service.