Graduation rate doesn’t matter as much as % that goes to college and % going to 4-year colleges.
Ask for your “school profile”. That’s what the adcoms will see and that’s how they’ll evaluate rigor. If 100% students attend 4-year colleges they’ll know “non honors” really weighs as much as honors elsewhere and they’ll adjust. If they can’t make that switch then they’re going to dock you for lack of rigor.
DUS keeps most options open and would be less selective than the “straight to major” requirements.