You’ve received some good advice above. The good news is you are DONE with main part of standardized testing and can focus on other things–especially pulling up your grades. The other good news is you are only a junior and have some time to think about your options, your goals, and how to position yourself.
Ask yourself what kind of school you want to attend. Small or large? Urban or rural? Do you want to pursue any ECs in college? What do you want to study? What makes you happy? What excites you? Read some college guidebooks to get a feel for different schools. Talk to lots of people. Read old threads here on CC. Maybe visit some more colleges between now and next summer. This self-inventory to help you identify your goals—and narrow your college list.
No need to apologize for being stuck. You are not stuck at all–you are only a junior! You are starting earlier than most kids. It’s great you are thinking about this with an open mind months before you really buckle down on application process.
Once you have a rough list of schools, think about what it takes to get admitted. Your application strategy will be entirely different for (just to pick three random examples) the University of Minnesota vs. Carleton vs. Stanford. You can probably get into some schools purely based on test scores and GPA. Other reach schools will want to see something more. The higher the selectivity, the more strategic and unique you have to be.
Now is the time to think about how you want to sculpt the remainder of your high school experience. Consider your application from the point of view of an admissions officer who sees thousands of applications with similar demographic profiles (suburban white kid, good tests, etc). What’s unique about you? Being memorable doesn’t necessarily mean you have to have won an international medal and doesn’t necessarily mean you need an incredible life story of being born in a refugee camp, walking across a war-torn desert, crossing the ocean in a raft , landing in the US and then immediately founding a startup that you sell for $1 million. Rather, it could just be having a uniquely perceptive outlook on ordinary experience—the sign of an active mind—as shown in your essays. Think about how you want to shape the second half of high school. Do you want to do anything differently to maximize “wow” factor of your extracurriculars? You could really focus on some of your ECs—working to place highly at state mock trial tournament, state science competition, or whatever. Or are you happy continuing what you already do? Only you can decide.
Most importantly, work hard to pull up that GPA, which seems out of whack compared to your high ACT. You may want to take SAT subject tests in the spring, depending on your target schools. Some selective colleges will expect them. Some great schools won’t demand them at all. Given your performance on ACT you could probably do very well, especially if you prepare for them, and that can only help.
I’m gonna get slapped for saying this, but I think high test scores are a much better measure of intellectual capacity than GPA. GPA, however, is probably a better measure of how diligently you will apply yourself in college and is therefore often taken as a predictor of college success.
I suggest you look for quirky intellectual schools. Reed, maybe? If you are still growing in the “ability to apply yourself” area, avoid schools with an open curriculum. Those distribution requirements will guarantee you a decent education.
I agree with Wash U and Haverford. For the latter, you must have an interview and you will have to write a kick-butt essay to have any hope. Your upward grade trajectory will help, as it shows maturity, and I know some top schools, notably Stanford, don’t even look at freshman year GPA, and there are probably plenty of other schools that don’t, either. So there’s hope for you!
^About this: the first FIRST thing you do is talk with your parents about budget. Run the NPC on your state flagship, a private college you like, and a college you consider a safety for your stats. Discuss the results. What can they afford out of pocket (from income and savings)? Are they expecting you to earn a full-tuition scholarship and if so are they okay going to college wherever that full tuition scholarship is located?
Also, visit all sorts of colleges withn driving distance: a Catholic university, a local public college, your state flagship, a selective LAC, a small LAC with partnerships, a tech school…Even if you wouldn’t want to attend, this will give you an idea of what you like: do you want to be in class with 200 people or with 20? do you like the large campus even if it means taking a bus to go from class to class or would you rather walk? Do you enjoy the idea of a core? DO you want to be the “big fish” in a small pond with all the advantages it brings, or would you rather be one among many bright fish?
Borrow a Fiske GUide and a Princeton review’s best colleges from your school library and find 10 colleges you hadn’t heard of and found that you liked.
The SAT used to be marketed as an “aptitude” (what the A in SAT used to mean decades ago) test. I.e. an IQ test. However, like other IQ tests, it is still influenced by environmental factors (including schooling and coaching – high school English teachers would make learning SAT vocabulary words a weekly part of English classes, for example). Now, it is not so much marketed as such (A was changed to “assessment”, then more recently SAT is just SAT, not “Scholastic A______ Test”), though it is still widely seen as such, since it is much less focused on specific content knowledge than other tests like the SAT subject (formerly Achievement) tests, AP tests, and many other standardized tests.
Many studies do show that HS GPA is a better predictor of college GPA than SAT scores, but the likely reason SAT scores are still used is that high schools in the US are not very consistent with course content and grading policies.
@flytocollege I would take a look at Case Western. Nice mid-sized research university with both tech and liberal arts programs. They like high test scores. Demonstrated interest is also important.
You seem to be interested in quality LACs. I would add Macalester and St. Olaf if they are not too close to home.
In Ohio, you’d probably fare well at Denison and College of Wooster and might have a shot at Oberlin.
As others have mentioned, do confirm the financials with your parents. It was a rude awakening for us to discover how much college costs have risen.
The above schools all offer merit-based scholarships in the 20-30K range if your family does not qualify for need based aid.
Finally, you might want to consider taking a couple of SAT subject tests as you seem to do well on standardized tests. Subjects for which you have taken AP courses and have done well would be logical picks. My D applied to places where they were considered, but not required, and I do believe they provided a boost to her applications.
Although I disagree regarding skipping grades, based on this along with the other results stating the importance of gpa, Massmomm’s view sounds like a prudent assessment.
Thank you everyone else that replied. I haven’t checked in for a while, but I’ll clear some things up.
I really don't know what I'm looking for in a college as of right now. This spring break, my family and I are going on a road trip to visit several different colleges, so hopefully I'll have something in mind soon.
My college costs are going to be partially covered by my extended family, as well as my parents. (I'm so thankful for them)
My freshman GPA was around a 3.7. I really struggled sophomore year, mainly due to social and mental health issues, and ended the year with a C average. I also just slacked off, and didn't put enough effort into my classes. As of right now, I have 5 As, 1 A- and 1 B, and am taking 3 AP classes.
I am a very good test taker, and had lots of free time throughout the summer preceding my junior year. I spent a ton of time studying and took a September ACT (my second time taking the ACT) and scored a 36.
I know little to nothing about SAT subject tests, except that many top schools require them as part of the application process. I plan to ask my counselor about them at my first meeting.
My top choice right now is (super reach) UChicago based on what I've read online, but my chances of acceptance are so low that I don't even know if it's worth the $40 application fee.
I haven't really been able to talk with my counselor, so most of my college information has really been solely from the internet. I apologize if anything I have asked or will ask has an obvious response.
Thank you all for putting so much effort into your replies, they’re all very helpful. I have a few more questions.
What are some good ways I can demonstrate in my application that I will collect my diploma four years later. I’m aware that HS GPA is mainly used to measure chances of college success, so I need to show that I will be successful in a different manner.
How “holistic” really is the application process. Will my application get read differently due to my lackluster GPA?
Can essays really “make or break” your application? I consider myself a pretty good writer, and am confident that I can write at least decent essays. Will this increase my chances any more than marginally?
Do any of you have any tips on what to look for on College visits? I’m mainly visiting colleges during spring break, but I’m visiting Carleton next week, and want to know what to look for.
Just want to thank everyone again. I know I’m only a junior but this whole process is extremely daunting to me, and my friends constantly flaunting their 4.0s and 3.9s doesn’t help much. I will check out some books from my library to try and find some lesser known colleges that I might want to look at. I will also do my best to get my GPA as high as possible before the end of junior year.
Thank you to everyone that replied! I haven’t checked in for a while, and all your comments are very helpful. I just want to clear a few things up.
I really don't know as of right now what I'm looking for in a college. This spring break, my family and I are going to take a road trip to visit a ton of colleges, so I'll hopefully have some idea after that.
My college costs are being partially covered by my extended family, as well as my parents. The closest estimate I can really get right now is that they will cover up to 40-50k a semester, and I will have to cover anything extra myself.
My GPA is the way it is because I had an awful sophomore year. I ended my freshman year with a 3.8 GPA. My sophomore year I dealt with social issues and mental health issues, as well as simple apathy towards my classes. I ended that year with a C average, which messed everything up. As of right now, I have 5 As, 1 A-, and 1 B. I am taking 3 AP classes. (Comp Sci, US History, Psych)
I am a very good test taker and a fast reader, and due to a ton of free time last summer, I was able to study a ton before taking the September ACT. (My second time taking the test.) I then scored a 36 (and was ecstatic!)
My top choice right now is (super reach) UChicago, but my chances of acceptance are so astronomically low that I question whether it's worth the $40 fee to apply.
I know my HS counselor is great resource to help me with all of this, but he's been focused on seniors up until the EA/ED dates, and hasn't had an opening to talk with me.
All I really know about SAT subject tests is that they are shorter tests on a single subject that a lot of top schools require as part of the application process. I plan to find out more about them from my counselor when I can finally get a meeting with him.
@mamaedefamilia I recently learned about CWR from a friend's parent, after looking at it a bit on Naviance I will definitely be looking into it!
@oldschooldad Wow, thanks for all the advice. I will try my best with my ECs, and hopefully will be able to make them into something memorable. If not with them, then maybe something else!
I have a few more questions. Thank you all for answering my previous ones.
How “holistic” really is the application process? Will my application be read differently because of my lackluster GPA?
How much can essays “make or break” your application. I consider myself a pretty good writer and believe I will have at least decent essays. Will essays be able to at least somewhat make myself at least somewhat more competitive in an applicant pool?
I am aware that HS GPA is used to measure potential success in college. Can any of you recommend ways I can demonstrate that I will be receiving my diploma with flying colors at the end of my college education that could potentially somewhat make up for my GPA?
I’ve discovered that for my situation there is a somewhat “blurred line” between matches and reaches. (ex: I consider Grinnell, Colorado Coll, and UW Madison, and Case Western “matches,” but they all have very low acceptance rates, and I could easily be denied from all 4 of them.) What really makes a school a “match?”
What should I look for on a college visit? The majority of my college visiting will be done over spring break and in the summer, but I’m visiting Carleton next week and have no idea what to expect.
Thank you all again for providing me with all this feedback. I know that I’m only a junior, but this entire process is very daunting to me, especially considering that my friends all love to flaunt their 4.0s and 3.9s. Thank you all so much for taking the time to help me out.
I’ll be able to tell you how it all turned out within a month, but your stats sound very similar to those of my oldest son who applied to UChicago ED this year. His unweighted GPA was a smidge higher than yours and his ACT a smidge lower, he had a few more APs (3.6, 34, 10 APs by end of junior year with 5s in most), but his pattern - Sophomore grades are what drags his GPA down - is similar. If he does get in, I suspect his ECs will be what made the difference. He has some very unique and ECs; I’m his mom and still can’t believe what he’s done with them - the biggest risk is that colleges won’t believe they’re legit.
The regional UChicago rep said that once an applicant is past a certain base threshhold - which she wouldn’t elaborate on - then higher grades or test scores don’t help. In other words, once they believe an applicant is qualified to benefit from the education, the selection process moves on to what other characteristics the applicant has, whether they’re a fit and what the applicant will contribute to the school. Since the highly selective schools don’t disclose what the GPA threshhold is (and it probably varies by school and rigor of course schedule), there’s no way to know if a 3.5 makes that initial cut or not.
If it would be helpful, I can let you know after 12/19 if my son was accepted and can tell you more about his ECs at that time as well.
@milee30, given Chicago’s 8% acceptance rate, I suspect a 34 ACT / 1500 SAT and a 3.8 UW GPA is the base threshold for an unhooked applicant; our DD’s both applied EA last year and both were denied - one had an exceptional interview, according to the interviewer, but it didn’t matter as I assume they have piles of similar applicants. That said, best of luck to your son!
@milee30, U Chicago did see a big drop in applications, over 10%, for the Class of 2021 which can only help - unfortunately I think the crime problem in Chicago hasn’t been good for its visibility.
It’s all relative. Back in the Dark Ages (the '80s) I was interested in going to UChicago. Don’t remember how or why it was arranged, but UChicago invited me to visit - in February. As a hick who’d only lived in Florida, I didn’t even own a winter coat but layered on all the long sleeved clothes I owned and a few pairs of jeans and headed north. Perhaps I’m misremembering, but back then the school had a variety of pretty grimy, depressing buildings and there appeared to be much less of a “buffer zone” between the school and the surrounding, rough neighborhood. After the guide joked about what appeared to be an actual drug deal we observed right across the street from a campus building, she noticed my alarm. "Don’t worry! See all those white phones out there along the sidewalks? If there’s a problem, pick one up and campus security will come find you. If you’re being chased, you can just knock them off as you run by… they’ll eventually track your location down and help you. "
As a 90 pound geek who was well aware she did not blend in this new environment, I did a quick mental calculation of my chances at running through the 2’ snow faster than whoever was going to be chasing me and regretfully concluded I was not fast enough to attend.
When my son and I visited UChicago last year, it looked much better than it did in the 80s. The campus was clean and inviting, security was visible but not oppressive and while the school still borders some tough areas, those areas are now separated from the campus by more than a single street. It felt as safe as any urban campus and the crime stats we researched didn’t scare us off. We even made a point of taking public transportation and walked in the immediately surrounding area. Our conclusion was they should take the same basic safety precautions one would in most big cities, but that UChicago students are likely to survive their time there.
Crime in the US has generally fallen greatly since the 1980s. However, with respect to homicides, Chicago seems to have seen a smaller drop compared to other cities, and a large recent rise that has erased most of the drop. https://www.thetrace.org/2017/01/chicago-murder-rate-fatal-shootings/
The following article makes more comparisons with other cities. What the article does not mention is that many of the cities with recent large increases are among the more highly racially segregated cities in the US (St. Louis, Baltimore, Washington, Milwaukee, as well as Chicago). http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/data/ct-homicide-spikes-comparison-htmlstory.html
RE: Carleton visit. This is probably too late for you, but for any others who might be reading this, the best way to get a true feel for Carleton (or many other small LACs) is an overnight visit when classes are in session. Carleton has a long Winter Break (starts before Thanksgiving and ends after New Years). If you visit now, you’ll find a mostly empty campus. Many offices, classrooms, labs, dining halls, facilities and all the dorms are closed or on reduced hours, so you won’t see very much. Even the Arb is mostly barren trees and dead grass this time of year, although there can be an eerie beauty to that. You can imagine yourself being in a Lord of the Rings type movie or something like that.
RE: 1, 2, 3. My situation had some parallels to yours. I had a perfect 800 SAT math score, verbal score in the high 500s, perfect SAT subject scores, and while I can’t remember my ACT, it was fairly good, National Merit Semifinalist. My grades, however, were all over the place — everything from A+s to Ds. I’m not sure what my GPA was, but I think it was in the neighborhood of 3.4 or 3.5 (weighted) in my sophomore year, steadily improving afterwards. Class rank was somewhere in the top fifth, but not top tenth. Even back in my day, these stats were a little on the low side for Carleton. On the other hand, I wrote an essay about one of my extracurricular activities. It really impressed everyone who read it. One of my recommendations was from a teacher in one of my A+ classes and who knew that I had done a very significant amount of independent study in the subject. (The amount of time I devoted to that independent study was one reason for my uneven grades.)
I strongly suspect the combination of my essay and teacher recommendation was what got me in.
I applied to both Carleton and Reed and was accepted at both schools. In fact, they ended up being my top two choices because they were the only two schools that had everything I was looking for. They’re really not THAT different. In fact, I feel they are actually more alike than not. You can certainly find other schools that are much, much, much more culturally dissimilar. I might even go as far as to say that Reed is probably the closest thing to Carleton you can find in the Pacific Northwest.
I’ve returned to Carleton every few years or so since graduation, both during the school year and during reunion. My most recent visit was in the middle of spring term 2015. I also visited Reed last fall. Perhaps I caught them on an exceptionally boring day, but I did not see, hear or smell anything on the Reed campus that you would not see, hear or smell at Carleton.
Incidentally, I was definitely not alone in applying to both places. One of the schools (can’t remember which one, maybe both) sent something to me that showed the other as being one of the schools to which kids most often applied. So, apparently, there’s a non-insignificant overlap in the applicant pools of both colleges.
@hokupaa, got to remember that the admissions standards at the most prestigious schools were less transparent/not as high “back in the day”. Today, a 3.5 W GPA is a very unlikely admission to Carleton - Carleton gets plenty of applicants with 1500+ SAT and 4.0+ W GPA.
@ytippiz, @hokupaa - I’m with @hokuppa on this one. I too applied and was accepted to both, as did my cousin as did my daughter. I ended up going to Reed. There is a significant amount of overlap in applications between the schools and their similarities and strengths are much greater than their differences. I agree that, if at all possible, an overnight makes sense.