Unfortunately on M10 you’re going to see all kinds of inexplicable or disappointing behavior not least of which comes from ADCOMS who decline kids who are super qualified allegedly in favor of legacy or other kids… Just a reminder either you or your child could be super qualified and there will be no rhyme or reason apparent (at least to you) as to why your child was rejected and why some other equally good student was selected. Don’t take anything personally, it is what it is. Life and BS admissions is not necessarily a “fair” process.