<p>You should visit and see what you think on your own… my D also was accepted to Carleton, and chose Mudd. But you really need to decide yourself. I actually think any of them would probably be good choices. But I think each school has its own “flavor” and you need to be comfortable. All are also fairly difficult for admission, so you might apply to all – Mudd is especially hard to get into for males (guessing you are based on your user name).</p>