<p>Done right, this is not a simple task for most people. It is hard and takes a lot of work. @vvnstar has given some great advice. If you use the search feature, you can find old threads with advice on song choices, there are lots of them but it takes some digging to find them and lots of scanning to find “the good stuff.”</p>
<p>One basic way to start would be to go through and list the composers for all the Tony nominees for “Best Score” and “Best Musical” for the period in which you are interested (the nominees, not just the winners). Even though many of their works may fall on someone’s “overdone” list (beware of putting too much stock in many of these, by the way), they will have written lots of great stuff to choose from - there is a reason they were nominated! Then google them, see what they wrote, find the age appropriate ones using StageAgent, and start listening to them on youtube.</p>
<p>If you have not seen these already, here are some guidelines published by colleges that might help you:</p>
<p>“The College Audition Blog” by Matthew Edwards from Shenandoah has lots of really great advice (can’t post a link because it is a blog).</p>
<p>I would definitely recommend following all stated audition requirements, but beware of worrying about every "overdone’ list that you find - we only pay attention to such lists that are published by colleges. I once compiled several of the “overdone” lists floating around on the internet and the result eliminated a large portion of the Broadway Canon. When I showed it to an MT department head, he laughed and told me to throw it away.</p>
<p>Here is a long quote from @drjohn from Otterbein that I really like:</p>