Has your D visited both schools? Done OV’s at each? We have visited both, very different feel at each. Both are incredible academic schools, but one is in the middle of no where (Williams) in New England and other is in a small town and part of a college consortium all within a short walk of one another outside of LA. I don’t know about Williams, but do know of a soccer kid who got a positive pre-read at Pomona but was rejected on his ED1 app. Definitely ask those questions others have mentioned. These schools are very different she needs to visit.