Productive job search strategies for new grads

What I’m seeing/hearing from my family members who are currently on the recruiting side is that companies post openings externally that they have no intention of filling from the outside because that’s HR “policy”. D reports that almost all their new young hires were either already in the company co-op pipe line or were direct referrals from current employees. I wish companies would stop that practice!

I am also a big proponent of young people joining their professional societies and directly networking.

And so many kids have excuse after excuse for not going to career fairs but that’s where companies are going to hire. Make the time! Practice the elevator pitch! Research the companies you want to talk to and understand why you are a good fit.

And yes, some companies do prefer certain schools because they know their grads are well prepared. Those “top employer” lists should be available through first destination reports and could be a good starting point for students.

I’ll also add that if your school has peer career counseling where they pair you with recent grads, use it. It’s one more networking contact.

5 Likes

Probably because they have a rule that all openings have to be posted externally to make it at least theoretically possible to get hired without a connection or hook. But it seems ineffective in the cases you are seeing.

2 Likes

What is relevant:

1- at all stages of one’s career- “spray and pray” is highly inefficient as a job seeking strategy.

2- It is easy to blame technology but technology doesn’t set recruiting targets or strategies, humans do. So it is a waste of time positing that you were rejected because of AI. Figure out how NOT to get rejected, don’t fume about having the wrong keywords.

3- New grads are highly reluctant and somewhat resistant to doing the “hard but obvious” stuff. Plop down in your advisor’s office. Show up at a professor’s office hours with your resume. Make an appointment with the chair of your department. Prepare your elevator pitch- “I loved the lecture you delivered on sustainable design and the future of urban transportation. Here’s my resume– how would you suggest I go about getting a job in transportation, preferably with an organization working on “green” solutions?

It is frustrating to look for a job when the “low hanging fruit” of Linkedin and Ziprecruiter are tempting you to waste 5 hours a day scrolling and swiping. But human contact has never been more important. And for a recent college grad- you don’t need “prestigious” friends or elite family members. Stop complaining that you don’t have “connections”. Use the connections you already have. A professor that you adore. A supervisor from your work/study job who thought you were fantastic. The reference librarian who helped you get documents from an archive in Prague for a paper you wrote on Art Deco architecture. What have you been doing for four years if you don’t have actual humans you can ask for help with your job search???

And for those of you who believe my advice is irrelevant- hey, free advice from a stranger on the internet. You are free to ignore me.

And a quick addendum on AI and ATS systems…. I retract my comment that many systems are relatively unchanged in the last 20 years. But the changes are mostly the ones that don’t matter to candidates. They are very useful for the clients (big companies) because they create a seamless “lifecycle” for new hires. In the old days, recruiting used one system, comp and benefits used a different system, individual offices or divisions had their own HR trackers. Now, a company can input the data once and it will be picked up everywhere. This is a significant time and cost saving advantage for users- but doesn’t impact applicants. Another terrific (to recruiters at least) function is the ability to shuffle resumes/applications around the company. You don’t need to manually reach out to your colleague in London with a strong UK based candidate- you can put them into the queue (if you have the appropriate clearance of course) automatically.

So yes, technology marches forward. But new grads aren’t being manhandled by robots and their AI assisted overlords. If you are one of a few thousand applicants for a role at an industrial company looking to hire 10 new grads for a manufacturing and operations rotation… well, do the math.

1 Like

Any networking is probably better than nothing . Perhaps. But many/most faculty are very poorly connected into industry. For some majors such as CS, spray and pray may be unavoidable because opportunities are sparse and widely dispersed. And many companies in this space don’t present themselves at job fairs — except perhaps things like Grace Hopper. A lot of the suggestions are not applicable for many fields.

Not my daughter’s experience at all, albeit in engineering not CS.
She worked her entire senior year in a lab that had 38 corporate sponsors (big name, well known companies). Her specific project was with one of the big aerospace companies. The prof that runs that lab was extremely well connected and would have absolutely helped her if she hadn’t a job lined up. And he was far from alone at Purdue.

**

Knowing what you know now, is there anything you would have done differently in guiding your children with selecting colleges, how they spent their time with internships/research/co ops, and how they approached their job searches? Do you have advice for recent CS grads?

3 Likes

College Confidential thrives on diverse viewpoints, but it isn’t a debate society. Repeating the same perspective in different words doesn’t create a new argument, and it rarely changes minds. If you’ve already shared your thoughts, consider exploring other threads to give other voices some space.

Start working on internships as soon as you can. Freshman year if possible. These prof connections don’t work, because there aren’t many industry funded projects for CS profs. Departments are much bigger — Rutgers graduates a 1000 plus CS grads a year. Prof recs work in very special cases. Aggressively pursue referrals through people a year to four years ahead of you — because you will know them in person, and HR often takes their opinions seriously. Developing AI skills is highly important. Ofcourse a lot of leetcode prep is considered essential, but my kid also found consulting case prep helpful for some of the Swe interviews — seemingly unrelated. This is the current experience. I won’t post the experience from 3 years ago because the context is different in many ways.

1 Like

Maybe some individual profs are not well connected, but I bet at least some have good connections. Or maybe the connections the profs had weren’t useful for your kid’s desired jobs? Anyway, at least around here, I get the sense that our regular state schools have a lot of connections… and in many ways these schools can provide more practical connections than the “ivory tower” sort of academic schools. Industry reaches out to these schools to help them develop programs to meet hiring needs. (I am talking about schools like San Jose State, Cal Poly SLO, …)

1 Like

Maybe California schools are special. There is a lot of CS industry there. That’s good for them.

Every place has its local industries… the thread is not just about CS. :slight_smile:

Of course when a student is thinking about where to study, it can be relevant how connected the school is with local industries in the intended field of study, and this is a little more nuanced than just location (for example Cal Poly is sort of out in the middle of nowhere, but it has great industry connections).

In addition to professors and professional societies, student clubs may also provide connections. In my D’s intended area (biomedical engineering), it seems that the student clubs at many universities are very active in developing and maintaining these industry connections and we see a lot of site visits, field trips, workshops, etc.

4 Likes

You have some good points here.

I know a lot of recent young grads through my work. A substantial number have given up on these types of automated applications (not sure if that’s the right term) and are finding, or trying to find, jobs in more “old fashioned ways,” which is of course still important.

It does work for some people. My son got his previous job in recruiting because he had his profile set up on LinkedIn. He was approached by the recruiting firm he ended up working for. His degree and the summer internship were relevant to the position he got, but his GPA was not great. No doubt it all came down to his interviews.

He lived on LinkedIn once he got that job (salary and commission) and he was able to fill jobs in the finance sector. He was very motivated by the prospect of earning commission. Clearly not a job for everyone. This was in 2023, so pretty recent. Some companies do look at job boards.

Networking, career centers, career fairs, sending out hundreds of apps can all work for some people and not others. It can be daunting and persistence is important. So much of it depends on the person. There are a lot of great ideas in this thread.

2 Likes

My younger son got a job at a large asset manager in Nashville by the mass (mailing) application process. It was a pleasant surprise. This is on their portfolio management team. Not a CS job. Not going there. This is one of the two he got altogether.

Yes, my son was recruited for his current summer internship directly through his profile on LinkedIn. The recruiter was looking for people specifically connected with his engineering design team. It was sort of funny-not-funny that my son had initially applied to the same internship separately and had apparently been auto-rejected by the automated system… but then this recruiter found him through the team connections, the interviews were a breeze and he was hired. It was actually the #1 internship he wanted to land, so it worked out well in the end for him. Definitely agree that kids should keep their LinkedIn profile well-tended!

6 Likes

Having a current profile on linkedin is NOT the same thing as applying to a job posting.. when a recruiter seeks you out your odds are significantly higher than when you send in a resume to a mailbox! And congrats to your kids!

In areas where many companies come to your school to recruit –engineering, business, economics, etc be prepared and use the service as much as allowed. It was a long time ago now but I got several good jobs via on campus recruitment. I believe that is still the case at my school. I never just sent out blind resumes and hoped. Never had to. After that connections even though unknown to me at the time were key.

2 Likes

I just stumbled on a thread on Reddit about underrated strategies. If it’s all true, these seem like some very simple and effective strategies. EDIT: Link won’t post, so I will list, and I cannot vouch for any of this:

  • I just got an interview after dressing in a suit, walking to the office, and handing in a paper resume and cover letter.
  • Walk in with a few copies of resumes in a manilla envelope and a suit, slap those bad boys down, it will feel like a waste of an hour but it seemed to work for me.
  • When I interview at a company and move forward but I don’t get the position but other openings come up, I contact the original HR person that I had the phone screener with and see they can get me an interview.
  • I’ve been invited to interview at a place where I made it to the final rounds of interviews late last year (down to me and one other candidate) because I stayed in touch with their recruiter, and she thought of me when this position opened up.
  • Best underrated one for me was finding people who recently left the same role and asking what the team actually looks for. They’re usually more honest than hiring managers, and sometimes they’ll tell you exactly how to angle your resume before you apply
  • I sent a thank you email to the hiring manager but made sure to include a one-liner about a certain topic we talked about during the interview. It should be something that the hiring manager maybe hinted towards about what they are looking for in a candidate.
  • Apply between 4-7 AM est. skip cover letters. Actually research the company…. Practice? Try not to say “no” I don’t know” come up with a workaround. Do not say you are looking for a remote job with work life balance
  • Having a really public Instagram has done it for me
  • One that worked for me was applying to companies that just posted similar roles but not only the exact title. Sometimes the team has budget for 2 or 3 seats and the first listing is just the visible one
3 Likes

Informational conversations are underrated, but new grads often ask for them the wrong way. A short message that says what they are curious about and asks for 15 minutes gets far more replies than a vague request to pick someone’s brain. They should arrive with two or three specific questions and, near the end, ask who else they should talk to, which is how one contact becomes three. For interview heavy fields such as consulting, practicing out loud with a friend matters more than reading preparation material. A few live mock sessions reveal habits that no book will catch, so scheduling them early in the search is one of the most effective steps.

5 Likes