<p>If you know the PSAT score and your state, the cut-off scores for 2008 year i.e. joining college in 2010 has been posted on CC. You can search for that and that will tell you if she would have made it to the semi-finalist or not. If she has been in the Senior year for two years in two different schools, the first school (where she took the test) should know.</p>
<p>If you confirm that PSAT scores was equal or above the cut off for your state for that year (it varies a little bit from year to year) you could talk to NMSC. However, the chances that will agree to something that was done in a past year is not very high. They are busy with the current batch i.e. those who took the PSAT in 2009 and may not want to reopen the case of someone who took it in 2008. Does not hurt to try (other than phone call and some time), but be prepared they may so no.</p>