We do disagree
I have no problem with hypotheticals. What I have an issue with is not indicating that it’s a hypothetical. I have more of a problem that the original post was recently edited in such a way that older responses may not make sense anymore. Closing
The rules have been relaxed on that. At our discretion, we’ll allow in certain situations, e.g. an experienced users assisting an FGLI who does not know how much they don’t know and has no family member more familiar. I (wrongly) assumed that was the case here.