<p>I was just in the exact same situation. I visited Chicago and accepted there (because of the reputation for intellectualism, academic rigor, and quirkiness), but then was urged to visit Reed, and in just a few hours on campus realized that I needed to spend the next four years of my life there. For me, it was about the people at Reed, the wonderful, free-spirited and friendly students. And, while the prestige is much higher at Chicago, I got a strong impression that Reed academics are, in fact, right up there with Chicago’s.</p>
<p>One other thing I sensed is that intellectual life spills over into social life much more at Reed. While Chicago kids told drunken water sports stories or talked about off-campus spots, Reedies seemed to have much more substantial conversation. This impression may be due to my short time at Chicago, but the feeling I got regarding out of class conversation was strong.</p>
<p>At the end of the day, you have to go with your gut. There isn’t much use in going to the “right” school if your heart isn’t in it.</p>
<p>-Tyler</p>