For brief impressions of several liberal arts colleges, see reply #12: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/2123956-differences-between-top-east-coast-lacs-williams-amherst-swarthmore-bowdoin-middlebury-etc-p1.html.
@galileofigaro further to @TennisParent’s comments on Williams math department, I would add that double majoring is quite common at Williams, even in diverse subjects such as math and theater. If you choose not to double major, you still have the option to participate in theater as performance opportunities are open to all students, not just majors.
You should plan to submit a performance supplement with your application.
Williams has terrific theater facilities and while the Williamstown Theater Festival isn’t directly administered by the college, its influence rubs off.
While you were looking for schools that would be easier to get into, Tufts is one with strong math and tons of opportunities for theater participation. It will not feel like Williams or Swat, though, so ignore this suggestion if you know you want a smaller school.
Some Schools Mentioned, by Number of Recent Math Major (general) Graduates
Hamilton: 36
Swarthmore: 34
Bowdoin: 34
Amherst: 33
Vassar: 26
Williams: 23
Wesleyan: 22
Skidmore: 19
Lafayette: 16
Haverford: 15
Tufts: 15
Union: 10
Connecticut College: 4
In comparing schools of different sizes, you may want to normalize for enrollment. If considering this data in your decision, you will want to follow IPEDS for another year of data.
(Source: IPEDS.)
I’d include functional analysis as an essential topic to seek, and suggest number theory over numerical analysis as a more important topic for a pure mathematician. Algebra in the above context presumably refers to modern/abstract algebra. In the sub-area of logic, mathematics and philosophy may overlap.
There’s a big discrepancy between the number of Williams math majors reported by IPED and the number listed on Williams website. My guess is that the reason for the discrepancy is that Williams counts double majors twice and IPED only counts one major per student. Since about 40% of Williams students double major, the difference is significant.
IPED 23
Williams website 64
https://communications.williams.edu/media-relations/fast-facts/
So I’m super biased because I’m going to Brown, but I highly recommend Brown if you’re interested in a liberal arts college feel (~7000 undergraduates, but small class sizes at the upper level courses and lots of opportunities to collaborate w/professors due to the relatively small graduate student population) while also being at a top research university. The Open Curriculum gives students tons of freedom in choosing courses, and being able to S/NC (Pass/Fail) any course makes it easy to explore other passions or interests as electives during college, without the fear of getting a bad grade getting in the way. Brown also has multiple concentrations (majors) combining math with another field, and you can even make your own concentration!
The math concentration’s also super small w/only ~ 20 graduates per year, so similar to a LAC in terms of class sizes.
See math concentrations here: https://www.brown.edu/undergraduate_concentrations?keyword=math
Brown also has a super strong Applied Math program, and Brown’s Math Institute recently received a huge NSF grant (https://www.brown.edu/news/2020-07-13/icerm .) You should definitely take a look!
Note that the OP stated “I’m also applying to research universities, but this post is about LACs.”