"Revolutionary Thinking? Colleges Let Students Opt Out of Admissions Exams" article focuses on UChi

City libaries have internet access. I suspect the school library does too. I am not saying it is as easy, but it can be done.

The short answer is that this is pretty much inevitable. Here is the more complete answer:

  1. Intelligent people tend to make more money. The estimated correlations are not particularly high (around 0.3), but the trendline is clear.
  2. Intelligence is significantly hereditary. In other words, smart parents tend to have smart kids. The correlation on this is estimated at 0.8.
  3. Given 1 and 2 above, statistics makes it highly likely that a high income school district will have higher AVERAGE test scores than a lower income school district.

Note I am not saying there are no intelligent people in less wealthy school district. Nor am I saying all the students in the richer school district are intelligent. The average can mask a great deal of variation.

Because GPA and test scores reveal different information. Test scores provide a common framework for comparison but say nothing about a student’s grit or other personal skills that can set them up for success. The GPA tells about how a student did in their particular school system, but says nothing about how rigorous the high school actually is.

I contend that standardized tests are actually most useful for school systems that are not well known. Every college knows Lexington High School in Massachusetts, and a student’s courses and GPA will tell them everything they need to know about whether the student is ready for UChicago. In contrast, a 4.0 unweighted GPA from Podunk High School may not reveal much, particularly if coupled with a lack of APs.