Rice vs UPenn vs. Columbia ED

If you attend an elite LAC or National University, you should have the option to work as a paralegal at a major law firm in Wash DC or in New York City.

Typically, the firms request a 2 year non-binding committment. Working as a paralegal in a major law firm in a major city such as NYC, Wash DC or Chicago, will give you insight as to life in biglaw & expose you to others with similiar aspirations to attend law school & work for a major firm.

While paralegals do not make a great salary, if you work in litigation & a case that you are working on goes to trial, you can make in the vicinity of $100,000 due to overtime.

Typically you start work with your class or cohort of other paralegals & are given instructions & work assignments by the head of the paralegal dept.

If you want to go to one of the very elite law schools, I would go to an Ivy. Half of the students at Yale Law School came from the 8 Ivies + Stanford + UChicago. Columbia has 34 students at YLS. JHU has 7 and Rice has 3. If don’t want to go to the very top, it likely doesn’t matter much.

As something of which to be aware, accelerated (6-year) law programs may not be that rare. Hamilton, for example, offers one with Columbia Law for students who pass the bar of admission.

https://www.hamilton.edu/academics/pre-law

Another undergraduate school to consider is Claremont McKenna College. Great curriculum for a career in business or in law.

Would I be at a disadvantage when applying to a top 10 law school if I went to Rice for my undergraduate degree as opposed to UPenn or Columbia?

If you would like, you can search “Top Lawyer Producer Schools – Infographic” for a sampling of 20 colleges with good track records in law school admission.

No, you would not be at a disadvantage when applying for a top 10 law school if you attend Rice University.

Is there a reason you’re restricting yourself to these three? As said above, you have a good shot at HYPS too. You really don’t want to get into Rice ED and later get into Harvard, if you don’t withdraw your apps.

One thing I will say: PLEASE DO NOT APPLY TO A COLLEGE ED UNLESS YOU ARE CERTAIN YOU WANT TO GO. Speaking from experience.

Agreed. I don’t think it’s that simple to say there are less grads from Rice (or any other school) at Yale than from the Ivies, therefore Rice is not a good choice. There are likely some other factors at work too. Rice is smaller than many of the other top schools, with less than 4,000 undergrads. Rice also has a high percent of STEM major undergrads. In 2019 about 1450 of their undergrads were engineering majors. That doesn’t mean the non-STEM get a bad education or the programs are not well respected. It just means that there are less of them entering non-STEM related graduate programs.

When our daughter was trying to decide on a school we told her that ALL the schools she was trying to decide between had good programs in her major and all had good opportunities in the things she thought she was interested in. We suggested she focus on what school had an environment where she felt she’d be comfortable taking advantage of the opportunities (i.e. focus on the culture, environment, etc.). We also suggested she not focus TOO much on her specific major. While that was important, we thought she should consider where she’d get a good education should she decide to change majors. I would say a large number of her friends have changed majors freshman year, some more than once.

OP: Since you mentioned M&A (mergers and acquisitions) as an area of law in which you are interested, you may find it interesting that during the past end of year bonus season partners at Cravath, Swaine & Moore received $5 million dollar bonuses of which $4 million was attributed to the firm’s M&A practice. (This law firm has offices in NYC & London). (I have no inside knowledge as this was published in one of the national legal newspapers.)

Life as an associate in a biglaw firm is not pleasant for most during the first few years as client contact is rare and others control your work life which is often 10 hours or longer per day. But the pay is great & enables most associates to pay off their sizable student loans in 4 or 5 years.

Entering the corporate world as an MBA is a much different experience than that of a young attorney entering biglaw as an associate. In short, more respect & more involvement.

M&A involves three main players:

Investment Banks (IB) finance & economics backgrounds are helpful as are accounting courses. Lots of work on Excel spreadsheets (modeling) & on putting together PowerPoint presentations. IB firms put together deals. Often have to find target firms to match the buyer’s interests.

Major law firms do the documents. Also, lots of review of existing documents at target entities. Usually billing is based on an hourly basis.

Accounting firms do valuations & tax work. Accounting firms typically get paid the least, but do the work that no one else wants to do or can do. Lots of Excel spreadsheet work. Lots of document gathering, assembling, & interpreting. Billing is done on an hourly basis.

Law Firms & Investment Banking firms make the most money off of M&A deals. Accounting firms make the least, but it is still lucrative.

One reason to attend an elite school (college or university) is that investment banks are very prestige conscious & tend to hire &, more importantly, tend to offer internships to, students at the most prestigious colleges & universities (target schools for hiring).

Of course, investment bankers do valuations work as well as putting deals together.

I may be slightly biased, but Rice is an amazing school!

Two years ago Rice initiated a new program called The Rice Investment, deigned to make Rice more accessible to middle and lower income students. Those with incomes under $130K who qualify for financial aid will be eligible for full tuition scholarships. Those with incomes under $200K will be eligible for half tuition scholarships. Check it out.

African American male, rigorous academics, fantastic scores, significant ECs, and first generation too?

Columbia, Rice and Penn are all great schools, but IMHO you are setting your sights too low. RD to all the Ivies that appeal to you, and Duke and Rice too. Best of luck, and congrats on your impressive achievements!

His choices might have something to do with the locations. Just a hunch.

“I am a first-generation African American male and the first in my family to go to college.”

Don’t ED anywhere, you’re an excellent candidate, a 1530 first-gen AA will do well even among the colleges you’re considering. Don’t get locked into a college with ED especially if you have to compare financial aid packages, go with EA or SCEA colleges, you may be pleasantly surprised. If you want to stay on the east coast, you can SCEA to Harvard, Yale, Princeton or EA to Georgetown since your major is poly sci. You can also EA to you flagship (UGA) for a safety. As for your list, for poly sci, I’d go with Columbia, their poly-sci program is one of the best in the country.

“I would also like to attend an Ivy-League graduate school after earning my undergraduate degree and earn my MBA and JD graduate degrees, so which school would help me be admitted to such a school?”

If your preference is for ivies that’s fine, however you should note that Stanford, Chicago and Northwestern all have higher ranked grad schools than most of the ivies.

“No, you would not be at a disadvantage when applying for a top 10 law school if you attend Rice University.”

What are you basing that on? Columbia grads do much with top law schools than Rice, if you look at the data. Yale e.g. doesn’t publish how many from each undergrad school, but when they did, Columbia was usually 5th behind HYPS, Rice didn’t even have enough to be in the top-10.

I agree that you have an excellent chance at all of the top 20 schools, and you should think about EA (not binding like ED) to Harvard, Yale, Princeton, or Stanford, and then RD to others. Right now is good time to reach out to the admission rep for Atlanta from each school with an introductory email. Tell them you are interested in their school, your stats, first gen, and that you are an African American. A great way to bring up the URM is to ask about support and clubs aimed at URMs. Also, you can probably get application waivers from some schools.

Standard disclaimer that you should only apply ED if you are really, really sure you want to go somewhere. That’s what ED is for.

All three of these are excellent schools; they won’t differ much in terms of internship opportunities and the quality of their alumni network (although Columbia’s will be bigger than Rice’s; and UPenn’s will be bigger than Columbia’s). Research opportunities will be - well - different. All three are Research 1 universities - with the highest level of research activity among universities in the U.S. - but Rice is small university with just over 3,000 graduate students, whereas Columbia and Penn have much larger graduate student populations and research arms that span a very wide area. That doesn’t mean Rice’s are worse (students at LACs can get excellent research experiences, for example), just they’re going to feel and be different.

Personally, I thought the research opportunities and resources at Columbia were fantastic, and there were many great research opportunities and programs for undergraduates.

They’re all in large urban areas, but New York is one of the largest cities in the world with a multicultural population and (usually) trains that run 24 hours a day; Philadelphia is also a large city, but not as dense and with fewer amenities than New York; Houston is large and sprawling, and most places are probably accessed by car. Penn and Columbia may offer more extracurricular activities simply because of their size and location, but that doesn’t mean that they are better or the kinds of activities you specifcally want to be.

I went to Columbia for graduate school (2008-2014) and worked in undergraduate student services while there. The undergraduate culture is very stressy and competitive - but many of the students who are there tend to thrive on that, and they form tight bonds and are pretty supportive of one another. It’s a pretty diverse undergraduate body, both in terms of identity and personality/interests. There are a ton of niche EC activities to do on campus and around the city, but if you’re looking for school spirit and sports games, this is not the place for you, heh. Campus always felt very safe, but there are some less safe neighborhoods that border Morningside Heights.