As chance would have it, I visited many of these schools last summer (all except Georgetown and Carleton) with prospective applicants.
My favorite three schools:
- Middlebury
- Williams
- Colgate
All 3 of these schools are breathtakingly beautiful.
Middlebury has an outstanding English department; both Middlebury and Williams are great pre-law feeder schools.
You might need to get your SAT up to 1450, but my son has a good friend (ranked 2/160) who was deferred ED2 at Midd and later accepted RD with a 1400. (He did have great WE + XC.)
You seem incredibly well organized and write exceptionally well for a high school senior, so don’t sell yourself short!
You got this!