@jsmith98 you should definitely call the Honors office and find out why, or ask them to reconsider or ask how you can appeal. A 34 composite ACT and with a 4.15 weighted gpa (I assume 4.0 is an A or equivalent to 100) with rigorous courses taken and, I assume you took AP courses, then you deserve to find out why you were not admitted and ask them for reconsideration. It is possible that your Essay or your Honors Supplemental Essay on the Common App was poorly written and did not explain well why you want Honors and how you meet the five GOALS (Global Awareness, Original Inquiry, Academic Enrichment, Leadership and Service Engagement) could be the reason.