@2016paws, Do you already know that need-based aid is unworkable for your family? If you’re not sure, then, as mentioned, run the individual colleges’ net price calculators. This will give you a good idea of whether you qualify for enough need-based aid to make it workable for you. If need-based aid doesn’t work out, then you need to move to merit aid which is often a different list.
If you liked Kenyon, then you might look at Williams, Middlebury, Hamilton, Colby, Bowdoin, Grinnell, Carleton. Smith and Mt. Holyoke if you are female. Some of these offer both need and merit aid, some only need, so run the NPCs first and see how your need-based aid comes out.
You have the grades and scores to get into any of these schools, but your extracurriculars, essays and recommendations will also be important.