I think you need to think about the day to day experience because you can’t possibly find 2 schools that have less in common than these two, IMO.
All female vs co-ed?
936 students vs almost 20K?
Claremont (pop. 36K) vs Boston (pop. 680K+)?
No snowy winter vs annual average of 4’ of snow?
You really need to think about what the difference in your life is like at one as opposed to the other. What makes one person happy would be torture to someone else.