If you’re looking for elite schools, I’d say go ahead and take it. The worry about dropping in other areas really doesn’t mean much IMO - worst case, you stay with what you have. Single day or superscore, you’re no worse off. (Yes, Yale and maybe one or two others require all scores - but they say they “focus” on what is effectively superscoring. I suppose if you got all 25s it might be a concern…)
I’m pretty sure AOs are smart enough to know the difference between a 33,35,35,36 = 34.75 (35) and a 35,35,35,36=35.25 (35). They understand fractions and rounding. So I don’t think the argument that you need a 36 to make a difference is valid.