I think of high school as the foundation for your knowledge for life. If you don’t pursue a topic in college, your high school exposure will be all you know or the basis for self-learning. For that reason alone, I would pick APWH, a good survey course, over psych, which is more of an elective.
I would consider the rest of the schedule to make sure you have a good balance in terms of work and rigor.
You can take psych later or even in college. Colleges understand the relative rigor of these classes, btw.