Should I transfer to UMich from College of the Holy Cross?

OP: Any starting salary differences between U Michigan grads and Holy Cross grads are almost certainly due to regional differences regarding cost-of-living. It is more expensive to live in the NE US than in the Midwest US so starting salaries differ.

OP should not get “lost in a crowd” at a large university like U Michigan due to very specific interests that are reflected in living/learning houses, activities specific to her interests in publishing and literary work, and specific courses which contain like-minded students, instructors, and speakers to a specific industry.

LACs can be good for those undecided about their future career, whereas universities provide more specific, direct education, activities, and experienced guidance in one’s field of interest.

P.S. Job placement stats are better at U Michigan than at Holy Cross; Holy Cross placed 60% of of the known outcomes of it’s graduating class within 9 months of graduation. U Michigan job placement varies by major, but is higher in a shorter time frame (6 months).

Interesting AI powered/generated research list:

Top 7 Colleges With Best Job Placement (basically a list of workaholic schools populated by highly intelligent,motivated students):

1 Like

This is implying that most people who attend LACs are undecided about career goals. Many, many kids go to all types of colleges knowing exactly what they want to study. They declare a major at the start. My two did, one of whom attended an LAC, the other who attended a bigger public uni.

And many go to all types of colleges undeclared. In fact, a huge percentage of students who attend college are undeclared. As high as 50%. https://collegekickstart.wp.drake.edu/pros-and-cons-of-an-undecided-college-major/ As many as 75% of students change majors. That is one reason why most US colleges have curricular requirements encompassing liberal arts. Both Michigan and Holy Cross have similar curricular requirements.

There is no “only one way or another” here. The OP has valid reasons why they want to stay at their current college, based on what is, so far, a stellar experience for her, with top grades. There doesn’t seem to be a clear benefit to changing.

7 Likes

Getting tired of this thread, but I’ll respond to the statement quoted above.

For a career in publishing or as a literary agent as well as for editing, U Michigan offers very specific courses and internships on campus directly related to OP’s stated career interests. Additionally, professors , publishing professionals, grad students pursuing similar careers, on-campus speakers focused on OP’s specific career interests, business & law courses related to the publishing industry are present on U Michigan’s campus. Plus, the world-wide alumni base of Michigan should offer outstanding connections.

I agree with all your posts here. Michigan has fantastic “opportunities “if the student shows a bit of willingness to work for it. I have known too many people with great stories about that. I also think Michigan does give the OP a leg up nationally.

The problem is I am not hearing enough of the “Why “Michigan. All I am hearing is “Why “HC. It seems she’s trying to convince herself to go to Michigan vs the “Really wanting “to go to Michigan. I can give facts and try to convince her but it seems she would rather be where she is at.

This is your area of expertise.

You asked great questions also.

1 Like

All of this is true.

But reality is that in the real world, more people who work in publishing and allied fields did NOT go to Michigan vs. those who did. So the “Michigan advantage”- while substantial- is not exclusive to Michigan.

I think taking a pre-professional lens to the course work, volunteer work, and internships available at HC is going to help OP tremendously.

4 Likes

I think OP is long gone. And as some have pointed out, the deadline to accept a transfer to Michigan is also long gone. Time to close the thread?

3 Likes

Since neither Holy Cross nor UMich appear in the site, its relevance here is unclear.

3 Likes

@leryaya15 what did you decide to do…if you don’t mind sharing?

2 Likes

Hi everyone. Thank you all so much for your thoughtful responses. As for the deadline of choosing UMich, my parents had put down the down deposit while I made my decision. I have to make up my mind in about one week. I am definitely leaning towards staying at Holy Cross, because as amazing of a school Mich is, I don’t think I will ever feel like a true Wolverine when I have experienced being a Crusader. Additionally, I for-see myself staying in New England all my life, where Holy Cross is well known. A lot of you have given me really important things to think about and I appreciate that deeply. I have started reaching out to HC alums on Linkedin to help get more insight into career choices. I’ll update this thread once my final choice is made! Best wishes to you all.

13 Likes

Depositing at Michigan while staying enrolled at Holy Cross is a violation of admission rules and unethical. Did you ask Michigan for an extension? You have taken a lot of time after the deadline to make this decision and have probably taken a space from another candidate. Please make your decision TODAY.

2 Likes

This is a bit harsh. NACAC’s ‘rules’ aren’t as well delineated for transfers as they are for first years. To start with, college transfer acceptance deadlines aren’t coordinated around one date like they are for first years (May 1), and many will allow extensions, whatever their date is. Because of this it’s not uncommon that many potential transfer students have multiple enrollment deposits and also haven’t withdrawn from their first institution.

Also, many schools now require an enrollment deposit before they will even start working on transfer credits…and let’s be real, if most credits don’t transfer for gen Ed’s and/or major requirements, there are many students who ultimately can’t transfer because it would extend their time in college. Meaning, they need to keep their enrollment open at their old school. Data show a significant loss of credits for transfer students, on average. I have worked with plenty of transfer students and it’s not uncommon to have transfer credits not even worked out by the semester of enrollment. In that case the only students who can safely take that risk are full pay families.

My son is an example of this…we didn’t have full clarity on his transfer credits until October. He did enroll with the new institution anyway and although they accepted all of his credits, not enough of them fulfilled gen Ed’s and major requirements so it tacked on an extra semester.

8 Likes

I appreciate your response and understand what you’re saying, but that doesn’t appear to be what’s happening here. OP seems conflicted on where they want to attend. They haven’t mentioned uncertainty around transfer credits as a reason for not making the decision yet. I do believe they’ve probably already registered for classes at HC and may have housing secured at both places. This is a long overdue decision that needs to be made ASAP. My two cents.

1 Like

I don’t know all of OP’s situation. I would be surprised if Michigan has turned around final transfer credit evals already, but maybe OP has full info.

Generally I lean towards giving grace to students and parents because the admissions process is not student centered. Transfer admissions even more so than first year.

3 Likes

I’m all for giving grace, but it’s late July. And what about the kids on the transfer waitlist? They’ve probably been told the spots are filled.

Michigan is not expecting to yield all the transfers who have deposited. They have made enough offers taking that expected yield into account. It’s not a one for one relationship with the transfer waitlist. Assuming they even have one…they may have cut everyone loose by now who has not received an offer.

FWIW, Michigan requires an enrollment deposit before doing the transfer credit eval, and says the preliminary eval takes 4-6 weeks after receiving the deposit. Some students will fall out of the process at that point if they have to stay in school longer than 4 years.

Anyway, I wish OP good luck and would encourage them to decide soon, if only for their own psyche.

6 Likes

Thanks for coming back @leryaya15
I have some final thoughts, which might be useful to other students.

THIS is what will you get you what you want in life.

Valuing relationships is not a weakness, ever. Happiness is not a weakness.

If you search through CC, you might be able to find some posts with titles like “I wish I hadn’t transferred…Can I transfer back to my old school…Too late to transfer for this year?..” and similar. Some of these students seem to have left schools where they were thriving, for some “bigger name” school. Of course, people who have good outcomes with transferring probably aren’t posting here. (There’s a whole subforum on another site for people who want to transfer to “T20” schools before they even start college. Interesting reading.)

My point is that in transferring, you may not find what you think you will find. People should also consider if they are the type of person who enjoys taking risks, and to be prepared for whatever happens, good, bad or in between. But please NEVER view interpersonal skills as a weakness. They are a strength, no question.

Once you have some internship and/or work experience under your belt, the name of your college becomes less relevant. Many jobs are still all about people skills.

Best of luck, wherever you end up.

6 Likes

This!

Our kids went to HC and have successful legal and military careers. They both had great experiences. It’s a tight knit community and alumni help each other. However, if overall prestige is important to you (sounds like it is) then Michigan is the better choice. It has higher ranking and broader name recognition than Holy Cross. I’ll also take your word that Mich is better aligned with your career plans. The biggest issue is that the two schools are completely different culturally. You could end up feeling uncomfortable and thus not as productive or fulfilled.

2 Likes